Reviews for Cosimo's in Central Valley, NY
Great food, very reasonably priced for the taste and portion. We have had both lunch and dinner here, and we will surly be back... on our next trip. My husband had the calzone which was incredible. I had the salmon which was yummy too, the only thing I didn?tlike was the charred broccoli but I think it?s an acquired taste, the beans were great though. And our server was super nice andquick. Read more
Food and beverage were Bang on! Everything tasted so fresh and delicious. Drinks were made great, only thing is with the... Manhattan drink was not smoky as they usually are. Portobello mushroom was so tasty Pizza was well done, their crust was sodelicious and fresh Try their Chocolate no flour cake, very delicious And let but not least the host, Brittany was amazing andso quick with our order. Don?t even think twice, just try this place without any hesitation. Read more
This was a wonderful experience. We were not from the local area and stopped based on ease of location. The service was... impeccable and even with the restaurant being very busy on a Friday evening we were seated immediately without a reservation. The food was spectacular and portions very generous. The drinks were also brilliant and delicious as well as reasonably pricedfor the quality. The server was very friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the dishes and appropriate drink pairings. They take cash and credit cards. Read more
Overall we've had good experiences in the past, however tonight was a disaster. Ordered takeaway, and when we arrived the pizza... was ready and had already been out, but we waited an additional 20 minutes for the herb roasted chicken. So the pizza was coldof course, but we figured we could just warm it in the oven and no big deal. My partner was enjoying her meal and eating themashed potatoes, when suddenly almost vomited. I couldn't figure out why until she showed me the nail mixed in with thepotatoes. Unfortunately it was in her mouth when she found it. I don't know how this happens, I don't know how or why somebodyprepping the food wouldn't notice losing part of their nail, especially if this size. How would they not throw the batch outknowing this was in there. If this wasn't accidental, then it was done purposely. I honestly try to post only positivereviews, but this is truly foul. I don't know what else to say.. Read more
Had a great experience here on date night. The calamari was so crispy and seasoned perfectly. I ordered the herb baked shrimp,... the Shrimp were jumbo, Garlic & Herb Crumbs, Charred Scallion Wild Rice, Sauteed Baby Kale, it was phenomenal. I was very happywith my choice. My bf had the spicy chicken fusilli, he said it was okay, said it was somewhat bitter... For drinks I had thespicy margarita, it was so refreshing with the right amount of spice and the cream cheese carrot cake is a must for dessert. Somoist and delicious. I had a great time here. Service was excellent, waitress was very attentive, Will definitely return. Read more
Calamari was good with the sauce. A little greasy but a good starter. We had meatball pasta, shrimp pizza and mushroom pizza.... Meatballs tasted like frozen but pizzas were crunchy, thin and large enough for 2 people. Definitely I?ll try their pizza butnot sure about the pasta. Tiramisu was full of whipped cream and I didn?t like it but Crème brûlée was on point ???? Read more
First time at this location and it was to celebrate my sis-in-laws 50th. They put us in the wine room which was spacious and... private, great room! We had a dedicated server for our party, she was attentive, professional, helpful and fun! Now to thegood stuff, the food! Everything was delicious! To start, Fried calamari was fresh and flavorful and the antipasto misto wasbeautifully presented on a wood board, all delicious! Onto the main course, grilled chicken penne, sounds simple but just wow! The chicken had great flavor, fresh chunks of mozzarella throughout and homemade pesto..5 people got it and there were noleftovers. It was that good! I skipped dessert but had the Mexican coffee, perfectly prepared and just right on the alcohol(some places overdo the alcohol). Look forward to eating there again! Read more
*Not Recommend* *Extremely Loud Environment* *Waitress We Had Was The Worst* *Food was really good and came out fast, the drinks... took a while for some reason* The service was absolutely terrible! The Waitress ignored my empty drink at the edge of the table3 times, I than proceeded to find the manager to explain the situation of the negligence of the Waitress not taking intoconsideration my empty drink and when we asked for more bread and oil the Waitress only brought bread and no oil. The food wasgood however the service was absolutely terrible. Read more