Reviews for Hawthorne's New York Pizza and Bar Carmel Road in Charlotte, NC

Great food. Fast, friendly service. Reasonably priced. We loved the basil mozzarella pizza and baked ziti.

Let me just say the food here has always been really good as well as the service. We have been coming for 12 years. Until today... I never really paid attention to the prices, but my wife and I wanted a large pizza and 3 toppings and for some reason I noticedthe cost for extra toppings. $3.99 for all over 1 toppings. So the pizza was $17.99 and 3 toppings is an additional $12.00, soall in large pizza with 3 toppings is $30.00. Come on now, $3.99 per topping is outrageous and I don't want to hear inflation,supply chain etc etc etc. Your competitors are an average of $2.75 per topping. I am venting yes, but come on. We won't stopcoming here but cheese pizza it is moving forward. Read more

An actual restaurant rather than a pizza shop. Great and varied menu. At least 8 beers on tap and very nice selection of wines.... Friendly and well organized staff... Really on top of things. 2 people could easily share an 8" kids pizza {cheese orcheesepepperoni only}... Add a salad or appetizer and it's a lot Read more

My husband and I have been eating here for years but the service is now horrific. We just walked out. When we walked in, the... person didn?t even greet us but instead asked, ?are you going to eat here??. We sat for 15 minutes while 3 different teenageservers walked by and just looked at us. The restaurant was not busy. There was only 2 other tables sat and they were done. Theservers even walked by our table to bring them their checks and didn?t even acknowledge us. We got up and left while one of theservers just stood there staring at us. Love the food but will not be back to the Carmel road location with this low qualityservice. Read more

If I could give no stars I would. I received my order and my calamari was extremely over cooked and hard making it inedible. My... salad had a dead bug in it also making it inedible. Read more

On this day had a great experience with the Margherita Pizza and Salad. Great service as well.

Had a great lunch today of nothing but appetizers. We got the meatballs, calamari, mussels and mozzarella sticks. All were... cooked perfectly and arrived at the table hot and at the same time. Our server was quite pleasant and helpful, and was verypatient while we took our time with the menu. The manager Tim was engaging and was walking the restaurant talking with alltables. Place was clean and music was at a perfect level. Read more

This is now out go-to pizza place in South Charlotte. I love the Italian stromboli and my family always eats the cheese pizza.... Right now we are big fans on our menu faves, but eventually we plan to try some other items like the wings or salads. I onlywish there was a medium sized pizza. Read more