Reviews for Extreme Pizza in Charlottesville, VA

Wide range of different pizzas... My Yard Sale was very good!

Came in at 3:15 and ordered 18" pepperoni and jalapeño pizza and a salad and I was the only order in and it is now 4:35 and I... get my pizza, it's not even hot. I saw the kid behind the counter play on his phone more than anything. Read more

I'm going to leave 3 stars for the sole purpose of first visit here came to pick up a order I placed waiting in line now 7... minutes to pick up my order that's already done. Get a better system here. I want to run in and grab and go and I'm stillwaiting knowing this i prob wont be back...hopefully the pizza isn't bad and they loose more stars ???? so 16 minutes in totalto grab and go lol I can't blame the workers here either it's mismanagement. There should be 2 people up front. The poor girlcan't do all that's needed in a timely fashion and how dare management leave her in a position that they have. Shame on you. Read more

The pizza was just so bad it was no better than buying a frozen pie and taking it home. No flavor at all. Like plain canned... sauce and hardly any cheese. The crust is neither thin and crispy or full and chewy. The crust is just plain and tasteless aseating the box that pizzas come in. Pizza should be fun and exciting, full of flavor, a dash of garlic, a little basil, thearoma of olive oil. Plenty of gooey cheese and sauce that drips down your chin. The pizza is almost like plain damp cracker withsome melted cheese on top. See the photo, it will not inspire you. I do really like the restaurant space, it's a friendly andairy room with a little bar area and lots of glass. It's also clean and neat. I assume that the real purpose of the restaurantis to serve beer after the dinner hour, and take advantage of the outdoor space called The Yard, but the pizza here is not anattraction. I give it two stars instead of one because they are so clean and they have draft beer, not just bottles beer. Read more

I ordered three pizzas and all were exceedingly bad. One was missing an ingredient, though they did give me jalapenos instead... (the Hawaiian permutation; box pictured), one was almost baron (the walnut pizza; pizza pictured), and one had a bone on it (apork pizza; bone pictured). Moreover, the pizzas are smaller than any competitors similarly named size. The crust is bland andsmells like hose-water. The sauce is thin and bland. The whole lot was just plain bad. This try was a second go after I had asimilar experience a handful of months ago. That was terrible too. Do NOT order from here. Total rip off. Read more

Staying in the area tonight and was looking for late night options to eat, surprised to find most close early on a Friday night,... so pizza it was... Great customer service, easy order and easy delivery. Fast and efficient, price was reasonable. Breadstickswere amazing, not stingy on sauces at all. Pizza, however, wasn't overly impressive. Wife enjoyed it, for me, it had anincredible sweet taste that didn't stand out as one of my favorites. I definitely ate and enjoyed it for what it was, and wouldencourage others to give it a try, just not something that I personally was huge on or would eat often. Read more

Delivery Experience: Food was phenomenal! I've been looking for a good goat cheese pizza in cville, and this place did not... disappoint! Super delicious! Everything arrived quicker than expected and was packaged great. Driver was super friendly.Definitely ordering again soon. Read more

Over priced for what we ordered, and I wasnt super thrilled with the tastes and flavors. Pictures included are of there caprese... salad and a half kickin chicken, half cenoi fever pizza. Staff was friendly and place was clean. Read more