Reviews for Carmine's in Chatham, MA
Arrived excited for some pizza. Although it says online that it is open, it wasn't.
We just arrived in Chatham for a few days and had zero motivation to cook. Takeout pizza seemed to be a good option and we... thought we?d give Carmine?s a try. Worked out great. Service was excellent, pizza ready exactly on time and both the pepperonipizza and Greek salad very tasty. And the fresh baked lemon cookies were an extra treat! Read more
Very disappointed with the service. I called at 830pm when they close at 10pm and they said they were no longer taking orders.... Why would you not take orders an hour and a half prior to closing? So i called another local pizza shop that closed at 9pm andwithin 20 min of closing, were able to fulfill my order of 2 pizzas. That place knows how to actually run a business. Read more
Stopped in before leaving Chatham to head back home 6 hours with my wife and two boys. Pizza was good and the staff were very... kind and helpful as my two boys were rambunctious. Appreciated the kindness! Read more
pretty awful pizza for the price. overly crunchy/chewy. overcooked in a bad way. cheese tastes cheap and is also crunchy. sauce... is average. Read more
Grossest pizza I've had in a while. Got a slice of cheese in the evening for $4. It looked like it was made with no sauce,... stepped on by a boot, then deep fried. We had to wait 10 minutes in the restaurant for them to reheat the slices and/orresurrect them from the dead. I couldn't eat mine at all but my boyfriend's pepperoni slice was edible for him. Just go get a$0.99 slice of pizza at Cumbies up the street, it will probably be better Read more
The pizza here is great if you are looking for flavors with more complexity than a simple pizza joint. The crust is thick and... spongy with a simple sauce that is topped with gourmet toppings. As with most places on the cape, expect to wait a bit. Read more
Awesome pizza located right in downtown Chatham! Super fresh ingredients and always made quickly. Staff and the shop interior... are great too! Read more