Reviews for Cherry Grove Pizza in Cherry Grove, NY
Best pizza anywhere on fire island! Wish they took cards though.
BEST pizza on fire island hands down. It’s worth it to go to cherry grove for this pizza over the pizza in the pines. I love... the triple chocolate mousse cake too - v decadent. The grandma sicilian pizza with added onions, spinach, and pepperoni isYUMMYYYY. Read more
They sell by the slice if you don't want a whole pizza. It was very good and was thin crust pizza.
Pizza was amazing. Generous portions and topping. Meatballs where great. Staff is very attentive and fun/nice. Ate here twice.
Round trip 24.78km (biking and walking from field #5). Absolutely worth it! Haven’t had such delicious pizza, in a while, and... I have lived in Brooklyn for over 30 years. ???????????????????????? Read more
If you like the usual Italian pizza-pasta place, then you'll be fine here. The food is a bit better though and the staff is... cool. The prices are good, especially if you take into account the PORTIONS and also the fact that you're on Fire Island whereeverything is just so much more expensive. Overall a good experience. Read more
If your at Cherry Grove ocean walk in Fire Island, Cherry Grove Pizza is the place to go. I greeted by the really nice waitress,... who had a smile the whole time. She also made sure I got everything I needed and checked up on me to make sure a comfortableamount of times. I asked what she recommended, so I decided to go with the chicken hero. It was delicious, hot sub, 12’ andfulfilling. The cheese was on point and the bread was not hard on the ends and the chicken was perfect as expected. Great cooks.The other waitress was very nice, as I got up from my table she asked if everything was okay and if needed anything. I did notonly enjoy my food but the service inside and out was 5star. I love and will definitely go back. Read more
Nice outdoor seating area. DELICIOUS gluten free pizza!! One of the best I’ve had.