Reviews for Sand Castle in Cherry Grove, NY
My husband and I come here every year as part of our Fire Island day trip. Casual restaurant on the beach in Cherry Grove. Very... good food and friendly, attentive service. Read more
Maybe I went on an off day but the place was packed so I decided to eat there. The oysters were tiny. Plus the cocktail suace... didn't have much of a kick it tasted more like ketchup with the smallest pinch of horseradish. So over $30 for a dozen I wasleft disappointed. I also ordered the fish and Chips. The Chios delicious however the fish could of been better. Started offwith crunchy but quickly followed by slimy texture. I wished I orderd the burger because it looked very tasty. Read more
This is actually one of the best meals I?ve had in a few years. A chef friend of mine once said that there is an inverse... relationship between the quality of the view and the quality of the food. I have found that to be usually true, but not here.Sitting outdoors with a magnificent view of the ocean, we enjoyed a truly spectacular meal. The food is absolutely amazing. Thelemon pasta was the best pasta I?ve had in about 5 years! The short ribs were wonderful. The lava cake was probably the bestI?ve ever had. Our server Teddy was fantastic. It is so rare to have food of this quality, and almost impossible to find with aview like this one. Congratulations to the chef Noelle Grant. Simply, wow!!! Read more
I was really disappointed by the dinner last week. The service was fine but my friend ordered the steamers which she couldn?t... finish because they were so sandy. I had the Lemon shrimp which was really bad-Completely over salted. $35. Too bad because Ilike the location and the waiters are friendly. Read more
First time at this restaurant. Sat at the bar and the food and drinks were fine, though they were oit of several items. The... bartenders were very attentive and friendly. Unfortunately, a gentleman, apparently the owner/manager, walked up next to us andcalled out one of the bartenders repeatedly saying, "You need to leave, you're fired!" Despite the issues any supervisor haswith an employee, it should be handled discretely whenever possible and behind closed doors. No one deserves to be publiclyhumiliated. So many supervisors need proper training, but an owner should know better. We spoke to him and told him as much. Weare business owners and would never dream of humiliating or employees, publicly or privately. Hopefully he learns from this. Read more
A solid place. My family enjoyed a nice lunch here. The burgers, fries, kale salad and tuna melt were good. Our waiter Brandon... was wonderful. Also terrific water views. Read more
Staff was exceptionally nice, great seating and view. Unfortunately the food was micro portioned. I was almost expecting a... second serving lol. For the price paid you would expect something a bit more. It seems as though the portions from last yearhave been reduced even more. This makes me question making the trip out from the Pines to eat here. Read more
I love it here. I always want to go here. Everything about this place is perfect. I love the waiters and how friendly they are.... They are sweet, kind and just the right amount of chatty. The bartenders keep you totally entertained if you sit at thebar. More importantly, the food is very good! I love the food here and they are gluten free friendly. THEY HAVE GLUTEN FREEROLLS FOR THE LOBSTER ROLL. Don?t ask how many I had this summer or how much they cost. Between us and friends we?ve eaten thewhole menu and nothing has ever been short of delicious. Never had a disappointment. Lastly, the espresso martini is top notchno matter which bartender makes it. Read more