Reviews for OddFellows Ice Cream Co. in Chestnut Hill, MA

The owners could go back to what is more realistic ingredients instead of using additives like glucose, dextrose, and any other... artificial sweeteners. They also use commercial branded products like oreo cookies and food coloring I will head back to honeycomb creamery in cambridge or amormino gelato. Read more

Really tasty ice cream with creative flavours. You can also get pints. The local collab flavours are lots of fun as are the... boozy shakes and slushies. Their vegan ice cream is excellent too. Read more

We love this ice cream shop dearly. The flavors are so interesting and exotic. We always order the exotic tropical fruit flavor... if available. We miss the flavor of lemon ice tea! Read more

Awesome, Satisfying. They are very creative in making newer flavours and varieties of Iced products of Milk, Cream, Fruits,... Wines and Spirits. You feel like having me every time you eat out in and around this area in Newton. Good place for family partyas well. Read more

Pretty good ice cream spot in the beautiful chestnut hill area. The different varieties is really nice to have on the hard ice... cream with different unique flavors. The soft serve options only have 2 flavors unfortunately, would be great if they could adda couple more different flavors. It would definitely make for some interesting and tasteful options to have a twist ice creamcone with different flavors of soft serve. Overall really nice place service was prompt and friendly. Read more

This was not our intended destination, but so happy to have found it. Two flights split between 4 people and boozy apple cider.... The peanutbutter jelly ice cream was incredible. Definitely a crowd pleaser. The flights were $10 each, not cheap, but the icecream was totally worth it. Read more

This place is different. Look how they made me 3 nice scoops of ice-cream. Others tend to make a big gob! Try kitchen sink! It... was my surprise favorite. The decor was old skool. Super clean!! They used metal spoons to let you try different flavors.Suggestion: stop using anything plastic. Read more

Had a pretty fun time here. It was a beautiful day and they were bumping but not that crowded -- great patio seating that offers... lots of dog and people watching. We got the flight (6 tiny scoops for $10) and it was perfect. We tried the following flavors:basil chip (Boston special), miso cherry, buttermilk honey blueberry, coffee crunch, saffron passionfruit apricot, and oatmealcookie (v). Their vegan ice creams are oatmilk based -- the oatmeal cookie was a little one dimensional and easily our leastfavorite. Otherwise, the basil chip was phenomenal -- just bursting with basil flavor. The coffee crunch was pretty special forsuch a "basic" flavor -- the crunchy bits were truly bitter and coffee-y. The saffron passionfruit apricot was lovely and tart,the miso cherry was a super complex flavor that might be hit or miss for some (it was a hit for me, deeply savory yet full ofcherry flavor), and the buttermilk blueberry was excellent as well. Service was a bit...strange. The person manning theregister and coffee bar was clearly a little under-trained since they took a long time to rang us up and spent a ton of timelooking for a cap for the coffee the person in front of us ordered...so by the time we got to eat our ice cream, it was alreadygoing soft. Their ice cream tends to be a little more soft-textured (closer to gelato than hard ice cream) but on the plus side,they're very encouraging with trying out new flavors! We'll probably be back! Great addition to the Chestnut Hill area. Read more