Reviews for Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom in Cheyenne, WY
It was nice to be able to have an outdoor dining experience in Cheyenne. Service was good the outside patio area isn't... especially clean but it's an outside patio area... Not a lot of happy hour offerings but the beer is cold and the burgers aregood. Read more
Ordered delivery from Old Chicago tonight and was surprised! We haven't heard the best recently, but tonight they were on their... A game! The pepperoni rolls are ALWAYS my go too, and they were really good! They did forget the marinara but it wasn't neededat all. We ordered the 2 medium 2 topping pizzas for $24 and they were very cheesy good amount of toppings and overall goodflavor! Very happy tonight! Read more
I absolutely love the food. It is some of the best food I've ever had in all honesty. The decor is cool, it's not usually too... crowded, and they have some good variances for the bar, dining area, and outdoor seating. My biggest complaint is how long ittakes. Whether I go for pickup, in which case I wait forever for the staff to come around and finally get to me, or I'm diningin and the food takes forever. The staff is very friendly, so don't get me wrong. It's just a crazy amount of waiting. The foodand friendliness make up for the wait time and that's why I give them four stars. Read more
DO NOT EAT HERE: I ordered a Chicago style pizza thinking that it would a common Chicago style. Instead of was a glorified... Little Caesars or Domino's Pizza. It was the same price as a Chicago style pizza: about $32. When I arrived and saw the pizza Imentioned that it wasn't what I ordered. I thought that Chicago style meant deep dish and red sauce on top but this had all thetoppings on top of the pizza and the toppings were burnt. I picked off my toppings because I don't like burnt toppings. TrueChicago style means that the toppings are underneath the cheese; in fact, common culinary sense would determine that thetoppings should be underneath the cheese or what they will burn. Very disappointed. MY disappointment was even more because theydidn't offer any discount, coupon or compensation for my inconvenience or for not informing me. They do have a pizza that Iwanted but they call it a Detroit pizza. I probably will not even eat all the pizza because it was super greasy, hardly anysauce, and the toppings were burnt. However, the lady who received the payment for the pizza was very nice. Read more
We came here for lunch I have to say the food was actually pretty good despite the mix reviews. We shall return
Service was terrible, we waited almost an hour for our food and we also waited about 20 to 25 minutes to be seated. The food was... terrible and part of my pizza barely had toppings on it. Our server kept going to the other servers table asking if they wereokay and how their food tasted instead of checking with our table. The people behind us for there food before we did and theydidn't have to wait on a table to be seated. Our servers name was Johnny. Read more
The food was really good. What we didn't care for was waiting for almost an hour for our food. Our waiter did keep refilling our... drinks while we waited, but who wants that at lunch? Read more
Had a great dinner with my daughter tonight, had the Chicago 7 minus the mushrooms (thank goodness they listened, I ask this so... often and find mushrooms on my food). Good portion size for the pizza, the starter could have been a bit more robust (8 slicesof bread instead of six and a little more marinara would have been a value), but no points off for flavor being on point. Spentabout 40 on beverages, food and a starter. Taking two slices home. Shelly was very pleasant, will definitely come back. Read more