Reviews for Erie Cafe in Chicago, IL
Great dining experience. Drinks flowed with an attentive bartender. The food was outstanding with steaks the size of a football.... Also a wonderful atmosphere to chat with your friends... Read more
Great steaks and old school Italian dishes. Staff knowledgeable and friendly. I have been going here for thirty years and never... had a bad meal. A little pricey but worth it. Free valet parking. Great cottage dies. I highly recommend it. Still my favesteakhouse in Chicago. Great Italian dishes also. It gives off a great old School vibe Read more
The outside seating here was very nice and the waiter we had was very friendly, but the food didn’t really live up to the... rest. We ordered the $86 ribeye steak and it was really disappointing — super chewy and barely any salt or flavor. Besidesthat, the mixed greens were tasty and the Lyonnaise potatoes were decent. Read more
I ordered the Chilean Sea Bass - which was probably a 3/5. The fish was fresh but it was lacking something I couldn’t... completely figure it out. Some of the folks got 34 oz Ribeye and some got the fillet, they said it was very good. I alsoenjoyed the calamari quite a bit. Standard old school Italian fare nothing exceptional about it. However the server and theservice was excellent. Read more
The outside (across the street) patio is a perfect late summer spot. I had Prosecco and shared grilled calamari and ravioli with... friends. It’s a great spot for people - and dog - watching Read more
This place its really cool. Deliscous food! Martin is very kind and friendly. Outdoor is very nice. Thank you!
Went for my girlfriends birthday. We had a wonderful time. I order the pasta and seafood, delicious. My girlfriend ordered the... veal chop, delicious. Steaks and sides were also ordered. Everything was super delicious and our waiter was very kind andprofessional. Read more
I came in on a Monday at exactly 11am, opening time, for their lunch. Definitely knew this place was special immediately upon... entering. There was a feeling of elegance and age with the lightning and cedar ceilings along with the exposed brick wall. Service was perfect as expected, and my shaved prime rib sandwich ($19.00, website needs to be updated) was juicy and full ofthat slow roasted rib roast flavor. The sandwich is paired with fries and a delicate mustard/mayo to balance out the beef.Definitely recommended for celebrations and family gatherings- there is plenty of parking along Montgomery park. Read more