Reviews for Max and Issy's Pizzeria in Chicago, IL
We stumbled on this place one evening on a walk. Glad we stayed. The pizza was great and the staff was super friendly. It was... an old bar called Paddy Longs. So older reviews still talk about the bacon & the previous food. It’s now all about the pizza!!and they did an amazing job rehabbing it. The best part was the pizza chef, came out to your table with the pizza he made andwould check up on you. Very special experience from such a casual spot. They have a full bar too! I give this 5?? Jerry (thepigeon) gives it 6?? He loved the crust. Read more
Yes, Captain Bob is back at Maxi and Lizzy‘s pizzeria. The best pizza in Chicago, I know because I made the best pizza in... Chicago Fire Department, I made my own doll, I made my own sauce. Their pizza is great and it’s delicious! Read more
Super fresh ingredients makes all the difference. Great New York style pizza, got the Hot Honey Pepper pizza and the Apple... Italiano pizza. It was a good sized pizza given the price point, will definitely be back when looking for that authentic NYpizza feel and experience. Read more
Tried this place for the first time last weekend and LOVED it. It’s cute inside and has a very relaxed vibe. The Hot Honey... Pepper Pizza was delicious and they have some good beers on tap. So glad I discovered this place and will definitely be back. Read more
Originally Paddy Longs, they've transitioned to a pizza parlor. Great service, our server was very attentive and friendly,... frequently checking to make sure my guest and I were good on drinks and refills. Lots of locally sourced beverages andmaterials. Had a sour beer from Niles and the lager was a collaboration with another local brewery. Great pepperoni pizza, veryflavorful and juicy. Very cute space, it's been much brightened up in the interior and the patio portion is compact butperfectly situated to have a great view of the area, making it perfect place for a drink or bite to eat on a summer afternoon Read more
Excellent thin crust pizza! Absolutely delicious. Crust was baked perfectly crisp. You can tell all of the ingredients are top... quality. I just got plain cheese and I was so impressed at how good is is. Try it, you won’t be disappointed! Read more
Had a great late lunch here. Had the Bacon Bomb again with lots of leftovers which is a good thing!! The bartender/waiter was... great too! Had a fun time with him. The beer selection here is amazing!! The hummus is quite delicious also. Read more
If you love significantly overpaying for mediocre pizza and tiny appetizer portions...this is the place for you.