Reviews for Paulie Gee's Logan Square in Chicago, IL
A huge fan of the collectible decor that’s what got me in the door ???? Not the biggest fan of the food or it’s quality. The... pizza I ordered was soggy and topics were sliding off I’m aware it was busy so it might have been rushed. My partner’s pizzawas toastier but we were surprised to see the bill considering the portions of our food and the tip was automatically included.I wouldn’t have paid $7 for a caned kombucha was under the impression it was alcoholic ???? my bf asked for a side of pepperflakes but we were given a tiny portion of giardiniera which we later noticed we were charged a dollar for. I know inflation isgetting insane in the city but felt like this place couldn’t run out of ways to up charge/tax their clients Read more
I swear they do Detroit deep dish better than Detroit. Tall cheesy crust with the beautiful cup and char pepperonis. The sauce... has such a nice balance that's light and sweet. The dough is nice fluffy. Probably one of the best pizzas I've had in a longtime. The nutter butter cake. I don't even have words for it. Just get it if they have it. 11/10 would eat here twice in thesame week. Edit: I'm adding more to this review because I think this place deserves more credit. Please don't stop buyingthese magnificent cakes from Pie, Pie My Darling. These are some top tier desserts. Even if you have leftovers of this pizza itretains the delicious gooey look the next day. Now if only they offered a Detroit slice to go ???? Read more
The pizza was delicious, and the server was very attentive. I recommend the US Pizza Cup Winner! The soft drinks were all... bottled or canned, so their price was a bit steep considering no refills. The pizza is worth the price though. Read more
Stopped here as part of a pizza tour. The Detroit style pizza was the single best pizza I have ever had! Drizzled with spicy... honey, fresh tomatoes, crispy pepperoni's and the crust could be sold in a bakery. Worth a trip out of your way. Can't wait togo back. Read more
YIKES! Was hopeful on this place because they had Detroit style. Got one Detroit style and one wood fired specialty pizzas. The... Detroit was passable, no where close to the best I’ve had, but good. However, the wood fired was inedible and uncut.. surelyit was just a mistake, but when you combine the horrible crust with a worse presentation, not cutting the pizza is just theicing on the cake. Salad was good and order was complete and timely, though not inexpensive. Read more
The pizza is good. The crust is standard good. It’s not crispy and it’s not soggy. Tasty sausage and tasty parmigianno... Reggiano cheese. I didn’t like that the QR code menu asks for your phone number and name. And there are no physical menus. Ialmost didn’t bring my phone. 20% tip is automatically applied, but there’s a note on the table about that. Big place,quiet on a Sunday evening. Friendly but slow service. Read more
Went for a late night Friday dinner with my boyfriend and this place did not disappoint. Our hostess, server, and even the... bartender were SUPER cheerful and recommended some great options. I had a margarita and the vegan Fast Car which was DELICIOUS!I loved the ricotta dollops. The taste was so decadent! I just wish the cheese was warm as it was served cold. However, theflavors and the crust were amazing! Probably some of the best thin crust pizza I’ve had in Chicago. My boyfriend had theDetroit style pepperoni pizza and literally gobbled down the whole thing! He can’t wait to come back! Date night approved andexcited to visit another time. Read more
Yum! I highly recommend getting the U.S. Pizza Cup Winner. It came out crispy, warm and just absolutely delicious. Great Detroit... style with really unique flavors. They drizzle a hot honey sauce over the top which just gives it such a good flavor. The pizzawasn’t hug but was split into six slices and was thick enough for each of us to have two slices and leave satisfied. One of myfriends is more picky and he loves it too. We had a salad split among three friends and it was the perfect size for all three ofus to split. Read more