Loading

Reviews for Sarpino's Pizzeria Evanston in Chicago, IL

Diamonddog Day 1 year ago
2

I have been coming to this branch for around 6 years now and up until around 2 years ago, I had no complaints whatsoever. I... think they must have gone through a couple of changes of ownership? I have no idea but the quality and consistency is prettymuch to the point where I am going to look for another place to get pizza. I always order the same thing usually once or twice aweek so when I get a pizza that is totally unrecognizable both in the way it looks and the way it tastes compared to the lastone, there is a problem. I have been patient but that last one from two days ago was horrible. Hardly any cheese ( i orderextra) burned ( I like it well done) missing ingredients. It was bad. Read more

Lisa Tekmetarovic 1 year ago
5

Sarpinos does a great job with all their menu items. They bring together non typical flavors and definitely make their pizzas... unusual but super tasty. The also offer many items for vegetarians, which my family really appreciates. Their salads are moretypical, but really good, with fresh veggies and flavorful dressings. We have probably tried every item on their menu and neverbeen disappointed. Fast and accurate delivery. Friendly service, always. A many year family favorite for us. Read more

Robert Lustig 1 year ago
4

I've been a Sarpino's customer for a long time and for the most part have been satisfied with them. I get the lasagna often and... it is good although sometimes it is a little thin and doesn't fill up the aluminum container to the top which is a bitdisappointing when I'm hungry, but the generous sized bread sticks taste good and help fill me up.The steak pizza that Isometimes get is excellent and the FREE delivery is fast most of the time. Read more

Natalie Davis 1 year ago
5

I have ordered from Sarpinos for over five years. They have the best on line ordering app, awesome loyalty benefits, and have... amazing delivery service. I am a vegetarian and love how I can modify orders to accommodate to my preferences- they never gowrong- Sarpinos always gets it right, that is why they should be your go to for pizza, salad, and pastas! They are the best intown! Read more

Levi Moore 1 year ago
5

I get food delivered from here all the time. It is incredibly consistent. The portions are ample and they provide exactly what... you ordered. No surprises. The quality is very good and price-wise, the value is great. Read more

Bruce McMillan 1 year ago
5

Sarpino's Pizzeria Wrigleyville makes great pizzas from scratch using really fresh vegetables, something a lot of the chain... pizzarias don't seem to do. I think that makes their pizzas transcend in tastiness all others I've tried in Chicago. They make awide variety of pizzas along with other items while others may concentrate on just a few different ones. They also deliver forfree! Best of all they are open until 3 AM, great for those hungry at late hours :) Read more

Michael Mirrorcle 1 year ago
5

Pizza was superb. They make sure to read the special requests. My pizza was extra crispy and well done without being burnt.

Jordan Russell 5 years ago
5

This place has a phenomenal calzone!!! It is the best I have ever had. And I love food, it’s made to order right then and it... is all high quality ingredients and the sauce is so good you could almost drink it! When you walk in and see how mane pizza boxthis place go through in a week you will be blown away. I stop by every time I’m near and I live far in the suburbs and Istill go here a lot. Its making me hungry just typing this. Soooo good!!! Read more