Reviews for Celestino's New York Pizza in Chico, CA
If you're looking for a quick and easy slice of pizza, Celestino's is the place to go. The slices are thin and crispy, and they... taste just like the pizza you'd get in New York. Plus, the ordering process is quick and easy from the window. And if you're oncampus, you can easily walk there between classes. Just be sure to try their ranch sauce - it's delicious! Read more
Some of the best NY style pizza you can get on the West Coast: thin, crispy, doesn?t collapse when you hold it up. Only a... handful of places in SF and LA stand up to Celestino?s. Read more
Pizza always delicious. It?s now a walk up instead of a sit down restaurant but we loved getting our favourites none the less.... They gave us free water on a hottttt day. Thanks for the yummy grub Celestinos! Read more
The pizza is very good and the slices are large!!!! A lot of much flavor. Located right next to a park and Chico state You... really will not be disappointed if you?re craving pizza. Parking is fun, it?s Chico! Staff are super friendly Read more
I was in Chico visiting for training. I did a Google search to find a local pizza place by the slice. Celestino?s New York Pizza... came up and had an excellent review. I decided to go there to have a quick slice of pizza. To my dismay when I arrive there, Isaw a hand scribbled note taped to a pole stating that you had to go to a window to order. I approached the window. Nobody waseven standing at the register. I observed a female and several males working behind the counter and talking to each other in theback of the restaurant. There were no other customers. After some time, the female finally approached the counter to take myorder. I asked about their calzones and what was in them since I don?t order them very often. She rolled her eyes and with anattitude explained that the calzones only came in one size large and that were $8.99, then giving me an assortment of differenttypes of combinations I can get in a calzone including one that I could add up five of my own ingredients. She came off asperturbed that she had to explain what was in a Calzone and seemed in a hurry. So, to make life easy I ordered a slice ofsausage pizza and a bottled water. In the meantime, while waiting in the heat, I observed a small family order a pizza and somewater. The family then walked to their car to sit in it with the mother stating that it was too hot to stand outside and waitfor their order. The female who I was dealing with the above and who had taken the order of the family then appeared out a sidedoor and yelled several waters, placing several plastic cups and straws onto a dirty table outside the restaurant. She lookedaround and walked back in the restaurant and out of view before anybody picked them up. Another gentleman had approached toorder a slice of pepperoni pizza. She took his order immediately and within less than 30 seconds appeared out the side dooryelling a slice of pepperoni pizza placing the piece of pizza and uncovered paper plate on the same dirty t Read more
Definitely the worse out of the two in town. Other has better service and better pizza most the time. Would avoid this location... personally, but still not the worst pizza this side of town. Read more
Great food, though I?ll stick to ordering at the window. The Online order system was a hassle and food was ready 10 mins later... than estimated time even though it?s a slow time on a Wednesday afternoon. ???? Read more
Wow wow wow this place really made up to the promise of a delicious NY Style pizza. Stiff, small, crisp crust with a slight bend... that allows for a great folded pizza! Hot damn! ???? The staff was super courteous and hospitable. ?? Read more