Reviews for Tony's of Cincinnati in Cincinnati, OH
Definitely did not live up to the hype for us. We were seated promptly at our reservation time and almost immediately served... bread. Our server also came over quickly, introduced himself, and offered his recommendations. We placed our orders and werequickly served our cesar salads. The salad was great-loved the parmesan crisp and the dressing had great flavor! We were off toa great start! Then our entrees came. I ordered the filet with mashed potatoes and my husband ordered the NY strip with a bakedpotato. My food was pretty good(certainly not the best I've ever had) but overall, I was pleased. My husband's steak was notgood at all. It was incredibly chewy and tough. Did we let the server know? Well we would have if he was ever around. He wastaking care of a large party seated next to us that was continuously asking him for something...more drinks, extra sauce, etc.We finished our meals (with no drink refills ourselves) and waited. And waited. We were there for a birthday and had planned ondessert but just wanted to go at that point. We finally grabbed another server and asked her to please get our check so we couldleave. Our server then brought the check with no apologies, no offer of a discount, nothing. We paid and left extremelydisappointed. So if you are going with a large party, you will receive great service. If you aren't, good luck! Read more
Grill Lettuce as appetizer follow with Fries….Makn Entree Pasta Diavolo & Sea Bass along with Sweet Potato & Melted... Marshmallow….Dessert Chocolate Cake with Raspberry Syrup…overall good quality of good….Kaitlyn is our server and she wasthe best…Warm & Friendly ….definitely coming back in the future. P/s: Nice selection of wines especially California ???? Read more
Incredibly welcoming, impeccably decorated and outstanding service. Perfect for celebrating a special occasion, but also for... celebrating great food! It is a bit pricy, but their selections and preparation make it worth the price. We definitely plan toreturn! Read more
Wonderful dinner to celebrate some birthdays. Everyone's food was great, except my husband. They replaced his dinner... immediately. Read more
If ever in the area and wanting to enjoy some of the best surf and turf in the tristate. These photos were from my birthday... dinner with my lovely wife and one of my two daughters a several weeks ago. Food was spectacular as always .... On a second notewere heading ti there location in Lexington KY for reservations this evening !! Read more
Best dinner I’ve had. My husband and I arrived for our reservation early hoping to grab a drink at the bar but the bar was... packed. We were pleased to be seated within minutes of our arrival. The service was excellent. Our server Bianca took great careof us. She was knowledgeable about menu items. We had oysters and beef tartare as appetizers and both were amazing. The Caesarsalads were delicious. The filets we ordered were cooked to absolute perfection. One of the best steaks I’ve ever had. We werestuffed and had to take half our dinner and dessert (get the creme brûlée cheesecake!) to go. The restaurant was a littlenoisy but it didn’t bother us. The food, wine, and ambiance were unmatched. So nice to get out for a nice dinner. We can’twait to come back! Read more
The ribeye, cheesecake and chocolate mousse were the best of those items I've ever had. The lamb was pretty good, and the sweet... potato was perfect. Cream of asparagus soup was a delicious alternative to a salad. Only real complaint would be about thesports bar area. It really sticks out from the restaurant in a bad way and ruins the otherwise wonderful ambiance. Read more
Tony's was great! Heather and Aniah were awesome servers. Between the 4 of us, we had 2 filet mignon, 1 pork chop, and one... carbonara pasta. All the food was excellent. The service was top notch. Bus boys did a great job keeping table cleared off. The only complaint I had was it was quite loud inside. Had a hard time hearing the staff. Everything else was great! Read more