Reviews for Pizza Cottage in Circleville, OH
Pizza is tasty but pricey. We had the "All the way" 14" and a 14" pepperoni for $40. Logan did provide friendly service. The... pizza was ready when we arrived, and was fresh. Read more
Lunch special $8.99 I had personal cheese pizza, light sauce extra crispy with a salad (fresh and crunchy, was perfect. With... plenty of dressing options) And I think drink was included? Many diff ways to put the lunch special together (sub sandwiches,etc) Always a great stop when in Circleville and also a planned destination too! We drive 40 minutes and we'll worth it! Cleanclean clean, even bathrooms were immaculate! Also need to add that they have "take and bakes"! Put together perfectly w greatinstructions on how to finish baking at home after PC creates their masterpieces!! Yum!! ???? Read more
I had a great pizza. The service was good. Also the food came out at a reasonable pace. And the prices aren't terrible
Came in town for a weekend get away. Chose this delicious place for dinner. Called in to order take out. Very polite and... attentive staff. Food was a 10! Would recommend to anyone Read more
Bad experience tonight! 4 years ago I left a review of the best pizza around. Today I was given the wrong pizza and the person... taking the order also forgot the no Olives on the other half. As you can see this isn't a All the Way pizza like my wife paidfor either! So the person making it messed up also! It's a 30 minute drive to town for me out here on the other side of towneach way with gas being $4.09 a gallon plus over a hour of my time! The manager said they are training a couple of new peopletonight and they will mail me some coupons. What they should have done to make it right and fair would have been driving myCORRECT PIZZA out here to me with a full refund and a apology! They will have to work hard to get the good review back that Igave them 4 years ago! Read more
This could be the best pizza but I have no way of knowing. First you have to get through the awful smell in the entrance of... mold or body odor. Getting through that I stood at the counter with no help or even a hello for longer than I would like toadmit. The parking lot was empty, and plenty of employees there but don't seem interested in customers I guess. Read more
I ordered a medium pepperoni, onion and extra cheese. Just under 17 dollars. Estimated time was 20 minutes and received it... during that time. Thin crust, nice and crispy. You could tell it definitely had extra cheese. They add a very nice amount oftoppings. It was delicious. This was very greasy though. Dripping down your hand greasy. Read more
We ordered it to- go. Pizza is some of the best I've had!! The cheese that they use is really top notch. We had the Whole Hog... and it was Fantastic Read more