Reviews for I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill in Clermont, FL

The portions are generous but the taste of the food was unfortunately below average. The tomato sauce was plain. The pizza was... soggy and plain too. The salad was served just like on the photo, lettuce hanging on the table! There were only two tablesoccupied on a Saturday night? Read more

Was trying to enjoy my turkey and cheese cold sub! I got It and took my first bite and couldn?t taste no meat? I opened it up... and there was 1 whole slice of turkey meat in the whole sub! Picture was nice and all but I can?t eat bread and lettuce for $13. Read more

Been there twice so far this week, first day we enjoyed the two slice and soda lunch special for $5.99. excellent! Can't... remember the young man's name that was our waiter but he was spot on very pleasant. Then today we enjoyed the calzone lunchspecials once again excellent $9.99 each. We believe our waitress name was Sabrina, very nice and pleasant as well! A veryfriendly staff. You can't go wrong stopping by there and enjoying in a pleasant atmosphere and great food. We will be back!! Read more

Are twice in the January 2022 visit to the area and the first time with the young lady the service was absolutely perfect!! ... Quick and payed attention and overall as good as it could get... Next trip not at all.. management/owners need to get thatconsistent... Pizza was very good and the crust just as well, tiny draft beers, the few appetizer dishes we tried were allpretty good Read more

We love I Love NY Pizza! The lunch specials are a great price and even available on weekends! The owner is very friendly and... nice as well. We have never had a bad experience here. Read more

This place is so good! We got the cheese bread and Stromboli, so good! The service was amazing. The restaurant was very clean!... The pizza was good as well. Everything was very fresh! Read more

Sooo, this is my first review EVER but needed to be done. We are originally from NJ but have lived in TN for last 25+ years. On... vacation so we were looking for some good pizza (which is non-existent in TN). Tried this place (delivery) and got a side ofmeatballs to test out. Let me tell you?..FABULOUS! Real pizza like we are used to. So we went there to try out some entreestonight and it was true authentic Italian. If you know good Italian, the you know what I?m talking about (and I don?t mean OliveGarden?.blah) We all got something different and everyone LOVED it. Huge portions so we have dinner for another night. Chicken,eggplant, veal?..sooooo good. One of our favorites for our vacations. Definitely will be back. Bel, the manager was great! Sucha nice evening. Read more

Loved it, my family had dinner there this evening. Everything was delicious and hot, true authentic Italian food. Definitely be... back when we come back to the Orlando area. Looking forward to trying the pizza next time. The manager and staff was veryfriendly. There was an issue made with my meal and the manager without asking comp?d my meal. Read more