Reviews for Captain Tony's Pizza in Cleveland, OH

Their food is decent but not as good as it was some years ago when it was under different management. It's a good go 2 place... when you don't want to cook. Read more

Oookay. I rate STRICTLY ON TASTE! The ingredients are QUALITY. I prefer a greasy, tasty top quality pizza. I was impressed. The... mozzarella sticks were VERY good. The only thing we didn't like was the Italian sub, terrible. Overall, definitely going toorder again! Read more

Worst experience ever! There were 2 roaches crawling on the floor. The man who I believe is the boss or manger told me I was... lying and tried to kick me out before I could take pictures. DO NOT EAT HERE!! Read more

Fast and good. Perfect pickup after a Guardians game and a rapid ride back to the car. Right there on the square. Will be back.

My first time eating this pizza, and it beat all the other pizza I have tried. Gold star. Fast delivery and friendly... driver...Very Delicious!! Read more

Nothing new, old equipment, same old dough and toppings. Nice people working but My throat hurts after two slices and my stomach... is making a lot of noise. Pizza is not that hard to make. No innovative added to this franchise, Shaker Square deserves better.Who is Captain Toni? Read more

Captain Tony?s is a Shaker Square dining favorite of mine. Their deep dish pizza ????, salads ???? and calzones are all yummy.... The wait time is I usually 10-15mins so you can pick up lunch or dinner and be on your way quickly. My fav pizzas arefive-cheese, bbq chicken ???? pizza, and the honey mustard ???? chicken pizza. Their wings are good too. Definitely good eats Read more

My husband and I have been frequenting Captain Tony's since he first moved here 6 years ago, and we've always been happy with... their food and service. Delivery service is consistently faster than their estimates when you order over the phone. Best ofall, they are happy to customize your food for you (when my husband could no longer eat cheese due to a medical issue, they wereperfectly fine with making their Thai pizza for us without cheese). Read more