Reviews for Gaetano's Restaurant in Willoughby Hills, OH
Pizza tasted pretty, but it was kind of cold and the cheese wasn't fully melted. I ordered carry out. If you dine in the food... quality is probably better (as it is with most restaurants) Read more
Very disappointed. We ordered take out tonight for dinner - chicken parm, stuffed shells, garlic bread and fried dough. The... fried dough was probably the best part because it was covered in powder sugar. Noodles were overcooked, chicken was alsoovercooked and dry - almost tasted like it was microwaved. Bummer because we were really hoping for a good Italian place nearus. Read more
The 1st time we came here it was amazing we came back a few weeks later and our server remembered what kind of wine I had. This... is the best place in town and the service is always amazing and food is amazing and you get a large portion of food. Oh and thebread is amazing too.if you have not been here this is a place to try. Read more
You end up really full from the portion size you get from here. Chicken francese is by far the best dish. Eggplant parmesan was... very good as well. I'm a huge fan of tiramisu and only reason why I gave 4 out of 5 was that they don't make this dessertthemselves. You can tell it's frozen since mine was partially frozen on top while the bottom was warm on plate from being quickthawed. Next time I go I will have to try the fried dough they have since that is made in house. Read more
Horrible experience. I ordered at 6:10. I was told 6:30 for pickup. I got there at 6:40 and they had not even started the order.... 20 minutes later the girl finally says my order is ready. She handed me half of it. I had to ask for my pizza. Menu said fishsandwich with tomato, tarter sauce and lettuce. I requested no tomatoes. It did not even have the tarter sauce or lettuce. The"large" pizza is the size of a small and was burnt. The order was $48 and a waste of money. I would not recommend or return. Read more
Love the salad and house dressing. The bread is really good when brought our warm. Have had mixed reception from waitresses-... they dont all come off as warm and friendly but they do their jobs! They seem to warm up to regulars... Had one really nicewaitress so far. Have tried lasagna and chicken parm. They will def keep me coming back:)) Read more
Great food and service! We live nearby but had never been and were in the mood for Italian. The sauce was excellent. We will... definitely come again. Great if you like a smaller family feel restaurant. Awesome place for local dinners out as an alternativeto going downtown or to Little Italy. Read more
We came in with a very large party reservation and the staff were prepared for us! Food and service were awesome! Reasonable... prices, good wine, the lasagna looked amazing! I would definitely eat here again if I was a local. Read more