Reviews for The Hill in Closter, NJ
Beautiful and spacious place. The Host sat us right away. There was a band playing oldies by a large bar, music could be heard... in the whole restaurant. Our waitress was Maya, very sweet, attentive and accommodating. We ordered a bottle of wine, bottledwater and she brought us bread. We ordered the organic arugula salad with Asian Apples, avocado and cheese, delicious and fresh.The ceviche was fresh, delicate flavors and beautifully presented. For our main course, seared, everything Tuna with bak choyand mushrooms. We also ordered grouper over a bed of lentils. Both entrees were cooked to perfectly, generous portions andquite tasty. We shared dessert, cinnamon crusted cheesecake with dulce de leche, very delicate, tasty and not too sweet plusColombian coffee. We definitely had a wonderful dinner experience and will be back. Read more
Food was phenomenal. Drinks were on point. Love music was an added bonus. Frankie the Mâitre d' was exceptional as described... the foods in detail making everything sound so delicious. The staff was so attentive. Amber was such a delight. Daniel was alsovery attentive. Compliments to the Chef ?????????. Thanks so much Frankie. See you again soon. Read more
This was a wonderful surprise! Fabulous atmosphere, great friendly waitstaff, and the food was superb. We highly recommend The... Hill. We ate too fast and so only got a photo of dessert! Read more
The place is nice and the atmosphere is excellent. The service was very good, and the selection of wine and types of food was... excellent. The food itself was okay+ bit a bit pricey to the quality and taste. Overall we loved the experience and will comeback. Read more
Amazing amazing restaurant, I pass this place almost everyday coming home from work and finally decided to reserve a table. The... outside of the restaurant is decorated nice and the Christmas lights were a nice touch, Once you get inside you see abeautifully designed interior restaurant with ample space a big bar and a section for live music. The waiter was exceptionallynice and friendly and added a bit of a personal touch to the dinner. The drinks were great and the food was perfectly cooked,and usually I take a lot more pictures but the food was there and gone in an instant. Tells you how good it was! Will definitelyreturn. Read more
I am a pescatarian and my wife loves fish and other seafood, so we had a great, over-the-top lunch at The Hill to celebrate my... birthday in early November. We booked a table, but when we arrived found that we had the dining room all to ourselves. Theyoung man who greeted us (I believe his name is Ricky) also took our order for drinks and a half-dozen first courses. That wasway too much food and we took home leftovers, but it was one of the best lunches I've ever had. We had enjoyed a couple ofdinners at The Hill before the Covid-19 pandemic began in March 2020, and our lunch reminded us this fine-dining restaurant istops for seafood in northern New Jersey, if price is no object. We ordered Fish Tacos ($18), a Mahi-Mahi Ceviche ($15), anArugula Salad ($14), a Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail ($17) and side orders of Shishito Peppers ($10) and Fries ($8). My wife had a glassof white wine ($15) and I drank a sparkling wine ($12). Everything was delicious, but I recall the mahi-mahi in the ceviche wasbeautifully composed with avocado into a small tower, the cooked shrimp in the cocktail were some of the biggest I've seen, andsnapped when I bit into one; and the arugula salad was a knockout. I can't wait to splurge on another great seafood meal at TheHill. Read more
Had a wonderful time at The Hill. The staff are courteous, friendly and attentive. Ricky was our server and he was accomodating... and took care of all our requests promptly. The food was delicious from first course to dessert. The manager, Frank made sure tocheck in with our table multiple times. The restaurant decor is very pretty and perfect for the season. Would highly recommend. Read more
OVERPRICED! The setting is beautiful. Plenty of room at the bar. Such a shame the food is sooo pricey and was okay at best.... The tiny crab cake pictured was $20. The calamari was also a small portion and not great, the fries were okay. Sodisappointed.???? Read more