Reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Colleyville, TX

Oh MY oh mY !!! This place is amazing the pie was really tasty. Yesterday was my 1st visit of many to come. A little indulgence... should never feel guilty I believe I earned every bite! The pie and service should be at least a ten and the place was sparklingclean to boot. Read more

I am so glad I found this delicious pie shop. I was absolutely blown away by the amazing flavor of each pie we ordered. My... favorite pie by far was the apple pie! Sweet, salty, tart, everything an apple pie is meant to be. The only reason I'm givingthis location 4 stars was because the staff up front was a bit cold towards me. I'm not sure why; I greeted her happily and wasvery excited to pick up my order just to be taken back by her composure and response. Anyways aside from that delicious pies!!Will be coming back every now and again. Read more

Ding Dang, THE best chocolate chess pie ever!! The pies stand on their own but the owners seem to be good people too. There... have been multiple times I've been around town, the pie shop is donating pies or giving back to the community some how. Read more

The pies are great! Best around. I should know as I am a baker and know what other bake shops offer. Freshly made pie crusts,... fresh ingredients for the season. Freshly baked with all the care a precision craft and art would require of an artisan. Trythem out and ask for Sheila the Owner. She is a sweet heart and is serious about your Loving her pies. Happy Holidays Read more

Wanna piece of me? I mean Pie? I thought you?d never ask. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is worth the trip even if it?s way out of your... way. Fresh homemade pies thumbprint cookies, s real cool Magnolia-esque vibe?. This place is adorable. Oh and the pie? Irecommend the apple but you should also try the Cloud Nine which is any one of their pie flavors mixed up with Blue Bell. Yep.Together. Read more

Yummmm!!! You will not be disappointed in this pie shop! ???? This mini pie was chocolate, peanut butter and coconut and I... needed at least 3 more of them! ???? The crust was soft but firm and the flavor was just right. Not to sweet! You must stop byand say hi to the new owner Sheila because she is the sweetest human on the planet! Great pie and great company what more couldyou want? They have a different pie of the month, so that gives you a reason to check in with Sheila multiple times a year!???? Read more

Excellent coconut cream pie -the shortbread crust was the best I've ever had- and a ganache filled cookie that was so good. Cute... store that's a bit hard to get to right now because of construction but it's worth stopping in. They have a box of 12 2-inchpies for $19 that makes for a yummy donuts-on-friday substitute. Read more

I've been here twice, and have really enjoyed the pies. The decor is cute and makes for a nice atmosphere. I will say that I... wish they had silverware that isn't wooden. I guess I have a sensory issue that makes eating my pie there with a wooden forkunbearable. Read more