Reviews for Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom in Columbus, GA

My wife and I had a rather enjoyable experience at Old chicago. The menu had a lot of choices on it and I went with the Chicago... 7 calzone while my wife went with the individual size Thai pizza. Her pizza was excellent and very flavorful. My calzone wasacceptable but nothing out of the ordinary. The service was pretty good but nothing to write home about. Overall we had a goodexperience and I would recommend checking it out. They have plenty of TVs if you're into sports. There's also a bar sectionwhich looked pretty nice. Read more

As always, food was great. The restaurant was very busy on Friday evening. Food was hot and fresh. Service was alright... considering how busy they were. Went again today and still love this place. Read more

It was a lovely Monday afternoon when I visited this fine establishment. I walked up to the bar and was greeted by a gentleman... with a warm glowing smile. He asked what I'd like to drink and I chose a wonderfully balanced IPA by the name of Two HeartedAle. To eat, I ordered the Thai Pie. As I waited for my food to arrive I watched some sports on the beautiful flat-screentelevision they have above the bar. The next thing I knew my food had arrived! The aroma from the Thai sauce was divine. Thepizza was delicious and service was fantastic. I would definitely recommend this place! Read more

I probably should have read the reviews before ordering because my experience was similar to a lot of them. I ordered for my... husband and I. We had wings and Italian grinder Pizza large. I have to be completely honest the food was Not good at all. Thepizza and wings were SO DRY!!!!!!!! It looked and definitely tasted like it had been cooked several days before. The breadtoppings even the pizza sauce cheese and everything was DRY and Disgusting tasting honestly, Not fresh at all. Nothing helpedtried ranch and nothing could help. Even the wings were DRY. The curbside needs to be updated if you’re not actually doingcurbside just take it away. 5 wings for $10 that were so Dry and did not taste good we couldn’t even eat them. I’m not doinga second chance here it was just too unbearable. We were trying a new place and that went horribly. This day was 6/11/22. NeverEVER again!! Read more

3.5 Stars. Food was good, very tasty. However, I paid almost $15 for the pizza and it’s sooo small. (Slightly bigger than my... husbands hand). I got the crafted beer burger….it was a little soggy (but expected for delivery) and sweet potato fries notcrispy at all. It was very good though. I would order again but prob not the pizza. I could pay less for personal pan almostevery where else. Read more

Amazing food and really nice waitress. The wings are so good they have a nice Crisp on the outside and they're juicy on the... inside. The pizza was so good, perfect ratio of ingredients. The spicy pickles are a must for an appetizer they are just simplydelicious the spices used are very flavourful. The calzone is ok its a calzone it wasn't bad but I also didn't care for it, tobe quite honest I felt it lacked flavor. The Chicken Apple Walnut Salad is amazing , it's to die for. The salad just was veryfilling and the chicken was juicy all in all would definitely order again. The Mac and Cheese was smackin y'all. The sicilianrolls are also a must for an appetizer. Overall next time I visit Georgia I will definitely be back. 10/10 Read more

This place is amazing. Service is fantastic, food is wonderful and quality, and the environment is not only clean, but fun. We... got seated immediately when we walked in Friday night. Our waitress was super kind and on her game. We soon put in our ordersand our pizza took no time to get out to us! They also have gluten free cauliflower crust that TASTES GOOD! Beyond impressedwith our experience here. Highly recommend. Management, you have an awesome team of staff! Read more

First time going and it was great. It wasn't too busy and our waitress Taylor, I believe, was also wonderful. She was very... attentive and friendly. They have a large selection of beer. I don't care for beer, but the long list is definitely quiteinteresting. We didn't get Pizza, but pasta. Next time we go it will definitely be for pizza! Provolone sticks, kids pizza, kidsmac & cheese w/ fries, lasagna, and the spaghetti pie. Hot and fresh and didn't take long at all. Read more