Reviews for Godfather's Pizza in Columbus, NE
Jalepeno popper pizza is the best. Also all of the pizzas are great.
Not impressed. Lost our order causing us to find a different place to eat. 45 min to make a re-make a pizza isn't acceptable.... Also, no credit cards or corporate coupons accepted here. Read more
A rare unicorn of a pizza business these days. Cash only and no online ordering. Just old fashion call in and pay when you get... there. We got the large taco pizza and large cheeseburger pizza. Read more
If I had read the other reviews about being cash and check only I would not have placed the order, it is 2022 and Columbus is... not a small town. On top of the hassle of having to use their atm, and incurring extra fees for that, they were not pleasantwith me when I expressed my dissatisfaction with them not telling me over the phone that cards were not accepted. I was notrude about it I simply said it would have been nice to have been informed of this beforehand, the employee simply said "welleveryone knows we only take cash, like all the regulars". I'm not a regular, I am not from the area, out of town phone numbercould have been evidence of that. They did not care what I had to say because they already had my CASH in hand. After all thatwas said and done my kids who love pizza would barely touch theirs, they said it was not very good, I agreed with them. Read more
Best place in town for pizza!! Great staff!
We ordered a small taco pizza with no sour cream or hot sauce. There was both on the middle of your pizza plus it looked like it... has been dumped. The lid stuck to the pizza and pulled them toppings off when I opened it. It least the delivery driver wasfriendly. Read more
I enjoyed my mini pepperoni pizza.
Place is a joke says they deliver but yet everytime you call they lay the phone down and go talk to whomever and them come back... and say oh sorry we can't deliver there were backed up and don't have enough drivers that's funny walk in to pick pizza up whichwas just laying on counter not in a warmer or nothing along with everyone else's pizza and there's 6 of you just standing aroundbut yet your so busy......and really cash or check only come on get with the program people Read more