Reviews for Anthony's Pizzeria in Bexley, OH
Ordered from grubhub, and detroit pizza is up my alley. Columbus pizza is typically thin, and detroit style is a pan style with... a spicier sauce. This is the closest I have had in Columbus and for my first try love it! Heavy toppings with pan style crustmake this a winner. My small gripe is with the consistency, as the middle had a generous amount of oozing cheese and thecorners were a little dry. Some pieces were not cut, and some were tiny and misshapen.4.5 in my book and will definitely orderagain! Read more
Delivered via Grubhub. Pizza was a mess as the box was tipped during delivery, no fault of business but something to consider... with this type of pizza and a third party go-between (honestly it could have just slid if the box wasn't level in a backseat). In any case the pizza still tasted delicious. Lots of pep and sausage, maybe too much pep for me as some didnt getcrispy as I prefer (again partially the type of pizza). Good amount of quality cheese. It's greasy but it's Chi-style so kindaexpected. Dough is great, nice fermented flavor you forget exists when you eat too much corpo pizza. Just a bit of"undoneness" on the top layer of dough you find in a pizza this wet but not undercooked. Sauce is excellent. Very filling, twopieces will stuff you so that's good for three adults. If you add in breadsticks and salad you could stretch it to twice thatmany for a decent lunch. Sauce, dough, cheese The pizza trinity. I dub thee, St. Anthony's Pizzeria. 8 hours later, that lastpiece was quite tasty cold. Read more
Small pizza shop in Bexley, with a big delicious pizza taste. Anthony’s Pizzeria’s pizzas are delicious and amazingly... flavorful. Their sauce and cheese compliments any pizza toppings you add. It was reminiscent of a New York style pizza andtaste. Limited seating inside and their is outdoor seating as well. Parking is also limited. Nice and friendly staff. Decentprices. Read more
Never had deep dish. I drive semis and was in the area so I wanted to try it. Honestly a fantastic pizza. Will order again if... I’m ever in town again. Read more
Did not enjoy this at all. Order this for our work lunch over the weekend….got a cheese, a pepperoni and the yum yum chicken.... The deep dish was very soggy and not good. The other two were thin as a cracker and cooked way too long. Not a whole lot offlavor. Read more
If your a fan of New York style pizza ???? ????... Then Anthony's is the place for you. It's a casual small pizza shop on the... campus of Capital University next to the gym. After 8 p.m. the shop offers half price on individual slices. The pizza isdelicious. Try Anthony's Read more
I wanted to try a Detroit style pizza and this place was recommended by other pizza connoisseurs. We placed our order online and... drove across town to pick it up. We got there a little bit ahead of our pick up time but it was ready on time according to ourpick window. We were so hungry and wanted to try it fresh that we ate the first slice in the car. We got the Cadillac Detroitstyle and it was delicious. It had a generous amount of meat and cheese, crispy edges and a mild not overly sweet sauce. Thecrust was pretty dense and not what we expected. It had almost a biscuit like texture but it was still very tasty and we lovedthe buttery crusty corners. We will be back and look forward to trying other styles and combinations. No regrets on the burntroof of my mouth Read more
The margarita Pizza with pepp and onion brought me back to Grimaldis of Brooklyn. The crust and toppings were excellent but the... sauce was a bit wet so the slice didn’t hold up well unless folded the wrong way (big no no, but a tasty no no). The yum yumsticks are a great alternative to traditional cheesy bread. Would definitely recommend All around Read more