Reviews for Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse in Columbus, OH
Went for my friend's 30th birthday dinner. Great customer service, Thank you Sydney and Caleb if I remember correctly! Had 2... glasses of a delicious red wine I cannot remember. But it was a middle grade Cabernet at about $18 a glass. Ordered the friedcalamari, was not a fan. They tossed it in a sweet chili sauce which made it soggy. For dinner I ordered off the early nightsmenu. I had twin filets with the steak griffin sauce which came w/mashed potatoes and fried onions. I also ordered a Caesarsalad with anchovies. All very good. I tasted my friend's corn and it was delicious. Overall I would return. But I was notoverly impressed. I would definitely recommend going during happy hour or on Sundays where the early nights menu is offered allday. Read more
Jerrod was fantastic, so personable! He is what we’ll remember about this meal. That being said, for appetizers, we ordered... the crab cake and the bacon, which alone were enough for a meal. We ordered the Ryan Day Steak and the Kosar. They stole theshow ???? We also ordered the lobster Mac and the au gratin potatoes, which each surprised us in the best ways - we were sohappy with our experience. We ended our meal with the Flaming Irish Coffee (amazing!) and the chocolate cake, which reminded endof my great aunt’s homemade chocolate fudge sauce. What an incredible experience! Read more
Great food, even better service. These employees put the customer first and will do anything to assure that you have a great... time eating and enjoying the scenery of their restaurant. If I could put 6 starts I would. Read more
This was the first time I had dinner here and my wife and I truly enjoyed it! The steak and sides were excellent ! We also... enjoyed our server britnay, super friendly and attentive. Our dining experience was wonderful! All the servers were friendly,great conversations. I will definitely be back! Thank you ! Read more
We went for office dinner here. The food was nice. But I couldn’t find anything in chicken at this steakhouse, as i don’t... eat steak. (I know its steakhouse) but i think they can include at least one chicken item in the menu. I would love to go againif they add anything in chicken. Read more
Sub par. My expectations were not met for this dinner visit. For a premier steakhouse and one of the top restaurants in... Columbus, it was very underwhelming. Let me start with some positives: the server was great. She was attentive, fun and made usfeel welcome. They also acknowledged our anniversary with a staff signed card and desert. The decor is nice, albeit on the dimside, even for me, who likes the dinner setting to be dim. The rate spirits list they offer is quite impressive and broad. Themost disappointing part was the food: just average in quality. Steak was ok, my wife's steak was borderline burned and way overcooked. The sides were bland, loaded baked potato was cool, the butter inside cold and not melted. I honestly had better steakdinners at places that cost 4x less. Overall, not impressed, especially for the premium price of the meal. Read more
Honestly, very good, very indulgent and loads of fun… I don’t do steakhouse often, but I’m really glad we stopped here for... a birthday and Valentine’s Day celebration. Outstanding cut of beef, to die for potatoes au gratin, brussel sprouts, wine,drink selections, service, ambience and so on. It’s classic, it feels classy enough, it’s quiet and calm, the service ispristine. Few if any complaints, excellent meal! Read more
One of the best dining experiences I have had, mostly driven by our server Bitna (excuse the spelling!). She was warm, welcoming... and absolutely fantastically on point on everything. You need to give her a raise outside of tips - she is fantastic. Sheconnected with us, learned our kids names and was on top of everything. The food is also fantastic. We had a few apps andseveral sides and a few steaks and everything was delicious. We were a party of 6 adults and 3 young kids, so not the easiestto handle, but everything was just really good. Worth the money for sure. Read more