Reviews for J. Gilbert's Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood Columbus in Columbus, OH

This is our third or fourth time coming for Thanksgiving. Please note some restaurants are really good and then a holiday meal... is mediocre. The drinks were great. The bisque awesome as always and the rest was OK. Through the entire meal we heard squeakingwhich couldn’t tell if there was a bird or a mouse somewhere nearby. We will not go back next year. Read more

This restaurant did not disappoint in many categories with my first experience. From the dim, moody lighting, to the good food,... you will leave mostly satisfied with your experience. J. Gilbert’s fell short due to their pricing not adding up to theirtable etiquette. The wait staff allowed the table to continue to be crowded throughout the experience. When a table does notselect wine, wine glasses should be removed. In addition, empty appetizer plates should also be removed before adding fullentree dishes. At this point, you have dishes sitting on top of dishes which is never a great experience. Although pricing isnot considered high end, to the average individual, it would be, therefore table etiquette should hit the mark. Overall, thisis a lovely place to have a birthday dinner, fun night out, or any special occasion. The party I was with left satisfied. Read more

I got a salmon with asparagus and a carrot cake to go. The salmon is quite possibly the best roasted salmon I ever had. The... Carrot Cake was pretty good also. The inner icing was a bit sweet, but overall it was in my top 5. Read more

Atmosphere is outstanding and the food was delicious. Staff are very polite and professional. Went here for our anniversary and... we were sat in a small private room. Had a great time. Read more

This is definitely an adult-oriented restaurant, reflected in its menu offerings and prices (there is no "kid's menu"). The... decor is a cozy rustic style, with dim lighting, exposed brick, hardwood floors and fireplaces, which makes me want to visitagain in the colder months. They offer a decent wine list, and steak and seafood are the focus of the dinner menu. Your best betis to go for the Prix Fixe Menu, which offers a three-course meal at a set price (soup/salad; entree; dessert). Going this routewinds up costing less than if you were to purchase each course individually. Service was attentive and professional. My husbandis particular about steak, and he was not blown away by his filet mignon. It wasn't terrible, he said, but it was far from thebest he's ever had - just kind of "meh." Regardless, we had a good experience overall, and we will likely return in the future. Read more

Wonderful food, the service was great, would definitely go back. It's nice to sit in the bar area chill if you're going to be... having drinks with friends Read more

Decided to have a romantic dinner for the new year. We started out with cocktails from the menu. I had the berry martini and my... husband had the Mexican Poker Game or something like that. They were delicious. We had the Charcuterie Board for an appetizerand everything was wonderful. For our meals we had filets with sides and a bottle of wine that was amazing. Our filets werecooked perfectly to order and the sides were great. We had a lot of left overs! For desert I had the Crème Brûlée and myhusband had the cheese cake as well as a nice port. Our waiter was wonderful and never left us waiting despite the shortstaffing issues. All of our food was wonderful, the atmosphere was perfect and we enjoyed a great romantic dinner. Perfect wayto start the New Year. I recommend you give this restaurant a try and enjoy! Read more

My daughter and I enjoyed our experience. Jackson was our server. He was both energetic and attentive. The company sent a... birthday coupon making our experience even more enjoyable. We were also provided a dessert that my daughter loved. Thank you fora wonderful dinner. Read more