Reviews for Mitchell's Fish Market in Columbus, OH
Excellent seafood. Everything was very fresh and cooked to perfection. The wait staff were very helpful, friendly, and... accommodating. I highly recommend this location for a nice dinner out. Read more
Was staying at a nearby hotel, and decided to stop here for dinner. Eva was my server/bartender and was very nice. I enjoyed my... meal and drink! Read more
The best meal I’ve ever had! We went there for our wedding anniversary and we ordered the calamari, the seafood gumbo soup,... the salmon, and the shanghai sea food sampler. I hate calamari, but the calamari here is amazing!! The dipping sauce is 1000/10!Get the seafood gumbo! It’s very smoky and very delicious! I wish I could order a gallon of it. The salmon was the best salmonI’ve ever had. Way worth the price. The mashed potatoes that came with it were so creamy and delicious. The Shanghai seafoodsample was delicious as well, but too small of a portion. But I must say the sea scallops are mind blowing and the sauce thatcomes with the dish is phenomenal. Our waiter was very kind, quick, and responsive to our needs. We will be returning!! Read more
A nice fish spot in Columbus. Highly recommend the lobster bisque! Came for a special lunch. Staff was very friendly. Food was... pretty good. Many fried options which weren't what we expected but still yummy. A little pricey but delicious. Worth a try whenyou're in the area Read more
Visited with a party of 5. The representatives were friendly and professional upon arrival. The food was prepared perfectly and... very flavorful. Read more
Our server, Eva Monet, was a rock star! She was playing hostess, server, and bartender when we visited for lunch on Saturday,... February 26. She was very pleasant, on the ball, and suggested that I order the Shrimp Americana. A very good recommendation! Itwas amazing! My husband got crab cakes and lobster bisque - best lobster bisque I've ever had, and he felt the same. Side note -not in Mitchell's or Eva Monet's control - the couple that sat beside us was on a speaker call for practically the entire timethey were there. RUDE. Just thought I'd get that off my chest - what are people thinking?! We definitely still recommendColumbus Fish Market. Read more
Very Disappointing. Incredibly overpriced for really bad food. The photo of the fish sandwich sums it up. Small portion and... horribly cooked. A McDonald’s fish filet would have been a better choice. They seriously need to change their oil. Thepiece of fish was smoked…, way overcooked and tasted of rancid oil. Inedible. The fries were cold, dry and lifeless and thetwo bites of coleslaw were sour. And this was a $17+ dollar sandwich. Like I said, very disappointing. My wife order the $29lobster and shrimp stuffed cod. The best part of both meals was the cod. Not dry, and flavorful. The stuffing had zero lobsterand one minuscule shrimp. Three sprigs of uncooked asparagus and a serving of cold, uninspired mashed potatoes rounded out hermeal. There are a wealth of much better restaurants to compete for our business. I’d highly recommend you skip this place andtry Cap City or Morettis (same neighborhood) for a far superior meal at the same price point. Disappointing really doesn’tcapture things adequately, more like I was robbed. But you know the old adage, screw me once, shame on you…. This will beour last meal with Mitchell’s fish house. Read more
My experience at Columbus Fish Market was lovely. I made a reservation online, which was incredibly easy. We arrived a couple of... minutes after our reservation due to traffic, but were still seated right away. Everything from our drinks to our apps to ourentrees were just delightful. Everything arrived on time, and our glasses were never empty, thanks to our server. The onlycomplaint I will make is that the booths don't accommodate larger people very well. My husband is 6' 4". He could barely foldhimself into the space provided. Read more