Reviews for Panzera's Pizza of Upper Arlington in Columbus, OH

If you love cheese, then this is the place for you! Pizza is good and the owner is personable.

Lg., 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 sausage. I usually prefer sg. a bit over pp., but in this case their pp. is better, but still a better... sg. than the chains. Thin crust from homemade dough that doesn't seem to have any rise in it baked in a Blodgett oven withquality ingredients that beat any chain pizza around here. If anything, I'd have finished the pizza straight on the deck for thelast 30 seconds to get it as well done as the top. Reheated very nicely later (425, 6 minutes on metal tray to crisp it), maybeeven better than straight out of oven. Easy to miss & hidden on the side/back of a plaza, appears to be carryout only. Theowner and other guy working were nice dudes. Maybe straighten up some of the magazine clutter on the front counter, butotherwise, a pizza I'd gladly eat again. Read more

I love this thin crust pizza and it's nice to support a small business instead of a chain. Just wanted to provide an update... 3/31/2022 Small business with a great thin crust pie. I got a small pizza with extra cheese and I swear there's over a coupleof pounds of cheese on it! Go check him out. Read more

Just tried out a large sausage and pepperoni pizza and the cheesy garlic bread. Both were amazing and had tons of cheese. Crust... is tasty and on the thinner side, sauce is thick and flavorful and as I said before, tons of cheese. I highly recommendPanzeras. Read more

Nice local place and the owner is super friendly. Our favorite things to get are the subs, followed by pizza and the garlic... loaf. I love that the crust and sauce are totally homemade. Read more

????Closest to a NY Slice in Columbus, without a doubt. ????Quality ingredients, loads of cheese, perfect sauce. Crust is... foldable, even though it's in squares (????). This is our Go-To pizza in Columbus. ???? Carryout only. It's a one man show. Notconnected to Panzera's in Grandview. Read more

The pizza is really good and the owner cares about the quality of his ingredients. He gets he rolls for the subs from an Italian... bakery everything is fresh. Customer experience when ordering etc may not be the focus here but the food is and that's what'simportant and they are really nice. Read more

Called to place a pick up order and the owner was extremely friendly. Pizza was phenomenal - perfectly chewy dough, thick sauce... with a little spice, those thick pepperonis everyone likes. We had ours with banana peppers and highly recommend. The chef saladwas also wonderful with all the goods: cheese, fresh tomatoes, salami With pizza as good as this and such a friendly owner,supporting local business is easy. Planning to make this our regular pizza spot. Read more