Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Commack, NY

The food is always amazing …But I had a delivery issue and Andy the manager listened to my complaint, apologized and offered a... quick solution. I was so impressed with him..he really went the extra mile to turn a bad situation into a positive one. Read more

Very poor experience. I made a large to go order but wanted to eat a few slices there and was told I am not allowed to eat there... if I am ordering to go. I said I would sit at the bar and order a beer and was still told I am not allowed. I will not visitthis location again I had to eat in my car. I will stick to the Westbury location where they couldn't be nicer. Horribleexperience and I got sauce on my seat. Read more

Yummy and went above and beyond when Door Dash website recorded order incorrectly and included the incorrect pizza ingredients... (no cheese bc my daughter is allergic). Manager took my order and personally redelivered the correct order. And wings and saladalways delish. But next time, I’m using Grub Hub. Read more

Start with the positive: great server, food came out fast. The food? Don't get the rave. Not really cheap, and not really that... tasty. I'll stick to my local pizza parlors. Read more

Been to this place multiple times. Staff is always nice food is always way too expensive for what it is. twice have had rewards... that have ended in sorry but I cant honor this let me get the manager feels like a scam . Cheap family cups have to ask fornapkins Table uneven Pizza is small salad is average ,staff is nice price doesnt equate. This restaurant needs to up itsgame. It was the same pre pandemic as well. It was my birthday no biggie. Read more

Anthony’s is my go-to spot for happy hour and on the weekends. The food is fresh and delicious and the staff is incredibly... attentive. My friends and I return every weekend for the bartender Nick who creates a 10/10 experience for us every time. Ican’t recommend this place enough. (plus the new tiramisu is delicious) Read more

Really good pizza and an incredible rewards program! We had the roasted cauliflower (pictured) and the traditional (basically... their regular cheese). Both were delicious. The cheese pie was really good; our kids loved it. Totally worth it. The cauliflowerwas tasty, but would probably order something different next time. We signed up for their rewards program after our serverrecommended it and are really happy about the bonuses they offer! A free 12” for signing up, a birthday pizza… good stufffor sure. We sat at the outdoor seating in front of the restaurant. Really not bad at all considering that the restaurantfronts onto JTPKE. Read more

Love the place but part of tonight's pickup order looked like this. This should've never left the restaurant like this thinking... it's ok. Coal fired doesn't mean burnt. Let me know how your talk with management goes. Never ordering again. Read more