Reviews for Athenian Greek Taverna in Commack, NY
Very unassuming place from the outside. Smaller, cute, some outdoor seating. Clearly more than fast food but not expecting more... than a quick bite. ABSOLUTELY STUNNED to realize the food was as delicious as it was. The Athenian Spring Roll was everything.Our waitress Angie was super accommodating and pleasant to talk to. A little pricier but well worth it, we will be back soon Read more
I had Mediocre food and weak pineapple vodka. Example: the lemon potatoes were too oily. I sent it back, and the bartender... kindly took it off my check. Another example: I have had much better rice pudding. Last example: the $16 pineapple vodkabarely had any vodka. DO NOT GO OUT OF YOUR WAY TO EAT HERE. The best Greek Tavernas are in Queens. Read more
We heard so many good things about this restaurant so my husband and I are glad we finally got there. The lovely waitress was... helpful and seemed happy we were there. They give you the most delicious tzatziki sauce with pita bread and an orzo dish hello.We had the eggplant appetizer and shared a very big delicious salad with a Greek spring roll. It was very affordable. Even myleftovers are delicious. Definitely going back Read more
Cannot recommend at all Messy main course, too salty, barely traces of feta in greek salad, mushy fries, not a great service,... and not inexpensive either. I dined in and they brought me food in the bag. One (1) napkin. Liquid tzatziki? just no Read more
Strongly NOT recommended!!! Chicken souvlaki platter was salty and dry, roasted lemon potatoes were extremely oily and salty as... well, fries looked like leftovers. I guess people go there for the drinks. Read more
Food was really good! I was mad that I waited so long to try it. I got the Janni gyro with a side of fries, that came with... delicious spicy tzatzki sauce. The meat was seasoned wonderfully and every bite was perfect. The pita was lightly toasted butnot over crisped which is my preference. My wife had a small Greek salad which was still a very generous portion. Willdefinitely be returning! Read more
Absolutely amazing service. We started with a margarita flight which was incredible. The food continued to wow and impress. Only... superior to the food is the service we received. Such friendly and attentive staff. Not just one but all. I highly highlyrecommend. Read more
Came here with my family for a birthday dinner and i loved it. They start you with pita and tzatziki and some kind orzo in a... sauce. We shared an order of calamari which i enjoyed and for my main i got their yannis gyro with fries. I regret not gettingtheir lemon potatoes because they looked amazing when i saw them going to a different table. My parents got their Greek platterwhich was a huge portion of food. I got to pick at their grape leaves and pepperoncinis. We all left full and happy. Thewaitress even gave us some baklava to take home for a little birthday present. Read more