Reviews for New York Pizzeria in Cooperstown, NY
My mother(who is 95)always has 2 slices of cheese pizza and orders 2 slices of cheese and sausage to take home, I have had the... pizza by the slice and the calzone and they were delicious. This time I ordered the large mixed sub. They load these sandwichesup with so much meat I don't know how they can afford to stay in business. You better bring your appetite because these subs areHUGE. Every time I visit upstate NewYork (I was born in Cooperstown) I make it a point to visit this establishment atleast twiceduring my visit. My advise is next time your hungry make it a point to stop in and enjoy some great food an terrific atmosphere.Everyone here is very helpful and ready to help. The folks from Ft Plain Read more
Growing up in New York City this is the best pizza I?ve had in years? anti-pasta salad was amazing?Huge portions, great... service, great prices Highly recommend wish I could go back again Read more
Wow. I have lived here for about 6 years and I know there is alot of live for this place, but never was a fan. I keep on trying... different things and never was a fan. Then I heard they sell Boars head with their sub. I thought how bad can a sub be withBoars head. It was bad. All bread. Barely any meat and lettuce, tomato. I get more meat on a sandwich at Stewarts shops. Read more
Here for HOF weekend and this place is awesome! Had two 18 inch pizza for a family of 7 and we still had leftovers. Definitely... try the cheese sticks! Thank you from the Oliva family! #6 Read more
Delicious pizza and mozzarella sticks. Sticky tables and high chairs,, but yummo I haven't had pizza this good in I can't... remember when. 5 stars if things were a bit cleaner. I don't want to have to wipe the high chairs before we sit. Read more
Born and bred New Yorker and I gotta say there slices was way better than expected. Lunch special at $5 for 2 slices and a drink... had me feeling like I was back in the city, kind dudes, satisfying experience, can?t go wrong! Read more
Came into this site was taken care of quickly and with kindness family friendly great food options for all the picky eaters.... Pizza was very good and the bbq wings were cooked to perfection.the family had a good time. Recommend going alone or withfriends and family. Had alot of options and had a great experience. This site has 2 floor order down stairs eat up stairs Read more
This is not what I would call "NY Pizza". I ordered 2 slices with green peppers and onions. I got 2 plain slices with raw... peppers and onions and a couple of pieces of melted mozzarella on top. Fries were like the frozen shoe-string type, not typicalrestaurant style fries. My husband ordered a Chicken Club sandwich and it had 3 chicken nuggets with some lettuce on a hoagieroll. Very disappointing. Read more