Reviews for Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland in Cortland, NY
I've been here a few times and had food delivered a few times. All in all it's pretty good food besides the spaghetti in my... opinion. Quality is consistent. Service inside the store is friendly but not always fast. Delivery is kinda slow almost everytime but at least they bring everything you order. They're busy so be prepared for a wait...other than that I really enjoypontillos Read more
Order for delivery, chicken caesar salad and slice of cookies and cream pie. Order came to $23.53 including tip. Received an... hour later with no fork or napkins, and salad was very warm, croutons were soft and stale and chicken tasted old. Pie was goodexcept that it also was warm! Definitely not worth the price! Read more
Being not from the area and our Airbnb hosts owning the place we decided to try it out. The food was awesome. We got looks from... the locals(????) bc southern accents in Upstate NY but it is what it is. They were super nice, made sure we had what we neededand the food was AWESOME! Read more
Food was phenomenal. Quality looked fresh and food was still hot! Pizza tasted great and there wasn't too much grease. Wings... were great as ever. Delivery service was fast. Will definitely order again in the future. Read more
Great pizza if you can pick it up, not great if it's delivery, due to the standard delivery time of 1 hour, resulting in a... mostly soggy pizza crust, no matter the thickness. The wings are tasty. Photo is of 'easy money' super thin crust, whichreally isn't that thin. Read more
The food was amazing! The best Alfredo I have ever had! The only downside was our knifes were dirty. The decor of the... restaurant was super nice. Read more
Long time customer- My Order was Delivered 45 minutes before closing. As my wife and I normally do, we ordered amongst other... things, our favorite pizza "A mild chicken wing pizza medium size - 18$)To our shock the pizza was Disgusting and Unedible,burnt to the point of not being able to identify what was on this pizza, the chicken wing sauce was saturated all the way threwmaking the top of the pizza burnt and the bottom soggy! I Called today to notify the manager as they had closed shortly afterdelivering my order. I was told I was going to get nothing but a $5 credit for my next order. This is after being told due to itbeing the following day I was not entitled to anything but still was asked by the woman who answered the call "what is it I'mlooking to get out of this!?" I was dumbfounded and shocked that this is how I'm being treated because I am calling thefollowing day due to them closing. Disappointed customers that won't be ordering from them again. A company not willing to standby the products they serve is a company that is not worth ordering food from! Read more
This place is great for pizza, wings and subs. Their other items on the menu I don't know. I had the lasagna the other night. ... They claim it is homemade but it tasted bland and came from a box. Also, they used a lot of noodles and hardly any meat orcheese inside. I will think twice about ordering their Italian dishes again. The waitress we had was also annoying. I'll juststick with the pizza and subs for takeout. Read more