Reviews for Pudgie's Pizza in Cortland, NY
Stopped here for a few slices quick lunch. Okay priced, decent pizza . Good but didn't wow me
Windows were filthy!! It was like a McDonald's Pizza place. They did have very good Buffalo wings, which we had along with a... salad. Read more
Great place to grab a quick bite. The food is yummy and the service is great. Great prices as well. The charred wings are the... best. Read more
Food and service were great. Love the char grilled wings!! Haven't gotten food here in a very long time so im glad we decided to... try it again. Read more
Consistent food, usually good. Stromboli needs work for consistency. Bad is, is that they keep a record of complaints, (who... hasn't gotten a mistake?) When your number comes up, they can see every interaction, thus your biased on your order if you'veever complained ! It's wrong to judge a situation without knowing. Read more
Great sheet pizzas! The subs here are also amazing. It's all about the bread! The bread used for the subs is what the "secret"... is about the subs that make them top quality for the price and overall quality! Read more
The first time I went to Pudgies was in august of 2020. We ordered a pepperoni sheet pizza. It was very undercooked pizza. It... was like eating raw dough. The second time, was today. Ordered a medium pizza with sausage, onions and green peppers and 10medium hot boneless wings and 10 traditional mild wings. There were barely any onions or peppers on the pizza. Also, theboneless wings were very dry and barely had any sauce on them. However, the traditional wings were good. We also paid extra forextra blue cheese x2 and and extra medium hot sauce on the side. We didn?t receive any extra sauces that cost .55$ extra each. Icalled and asked if they could deliver the condiments and they agreed. They didn?t send the condiments until 50 minuteslater. I will not be ordering from here, again, Read more
I'm not sure I need to say anything more than YUM! Pudgie's strom is quite literally my favorite food, and I currently drive a... very willing two hours in order to indulge. The wings are delicious and the subs are yummo too. Every time I visit I'm met withfriendly staff. All around one of my favorite food spots anywhere! Read more