Reviews for DeMaggio's New York Pizza in Corvallis, OR

2 of our 3 orders made it to our table, 1 never made it. After 30 minutes we asked where it was and waited another 15 minutes.... After a total of an hour waiting we requested a refund. The food that we did receive was very good. Read more

Took over an hour to deliver a few miles away. Ordered ?white sauce? pasta with chicken which was completely bland and mushy.... Paid $6.50 for 5 mediocre wings. The upside was that there was so much raw flour under the pizza I could bake my own cake. Read more

Yummy pizza. In particular we really enjoy the mushroom pizza - having lived in two large pizza capital cities, I think... DeMaggio's does a very fine job. Read more

Totally understand the concept of demaggios. Still was less than desirable. Probably due to the heavy handed cook on the line... that day as certain ingredients when used in excess can over power a dish. Seems to be a fun place for the more refined collegecrowd. And if its trivia night and your not playing, avoid this place. We sat in a corner, away from the folks playing, andstill had the emcee heckle us about using our phones. We weren't playing and just planning our trip for the following day. Wontreturn. Read more

We have been here twice now. Laid back atmosphere, excellent pizza and I appreciate that they have some vegan options including... vegan cheese (I am lactose intolerant). Good choices of beer and cider, not a ton but there is something good in the mix. Youpick your own seat, order at the bar, collect plates silverware yourself and bus your table when you are done. Works for us aswe don't need to be waited on and we don't mind that at all. It's kid friendly too. Read more