Reviews for Pegasus in Coxsackie, NY
On a small trip we stopped here because it was one of the only places open and I'm glad we did. The employees were very friendly... and genuine, the restaurant was very comfortable to be in, and the food was really good. They have a good variety of food,including a year round Thanksgiving turkey dinner, burgers, and some Greek dishes. Overall a good experience. 10/10 wouldrecommend. Read more
Everything was handled well. We had a 50th HS reunion here. The food was great and the people were great to work with. It was... a good choice to have it here! Cairo, Durham 50th reunion. Read more
The chef needs to taste his product before it goes on a buffet.The soup was????. Imagine setting a buffet without enough soup... cups and dinner plates. With the prices of food today, it is a sin not to take pride in everything presented. I am aprofessional chef, two stars are two stars too many. Read more
Came in on a weeknight recently looking to try a new place from the same old restaurants in Catskill. We were the only... customers in the restaurant around 7 pm which was so incredibly refreshing, especially since we were trying to find a quietplace after a long day at work. We missed the dinner crowd by about 15 minutes. The Owner was extremely courteous as was ourserver Kristen. The food was surprisingly excellent. Nice sized entree portions and not a high end price. Ordered thechicken marsala which had a thin brown sauce and excellent flavoring and nice size mushrooms, served over pasta. Warm freshbaked rolls and salads included with the entrees. Our server kept her attention to us, and was only there when she needed tobe. They didn't try to rush us out at all even though it was still before closing time. The Owner had to vacuum the front area,but she closed the door to the dining room so as to not disturb us during our dinner. That thoughtfulness did not go unnoticedand I certainly appreciated that extra courtesy. I always get mozzarella sticks wherever we go, sometimes good and sometimesbad depending on where we go, but here the mozzarella sticks were some of the better ones we have eaten. We thoroughly enjoyedour dinner and quietness, although we understand that being the only ones here isn't usually the norm. They are usually busy,wherever we have been past before. We will definitely be back at some point. Great place. I'd give that meal we had an A+ forjust about everything being perfect. I could see why it's a popular restaurant. Read more
The very nice staff make this a great family palace to eat! Quieter environment than most, smaller menu with good food options,... and reasonably priced! This is one of my favorite places in the area to eat, with just my wife or with our whole family! Read more
The waitress was fantastic. She was accommodating and knew when to give you space. The food was delicious. I had the chicken... marsalla and it melted in my mouth. I suspect it was organic chicken. Very reasonably priced. I am definitely going back. Read more
Great local place for an authentic upstate experience. Friendly waitstaff. Food was great, loved the steak sandwich, prosciutto... panini, big juicy burgers and the fries were cooked to perfection. Kids pizza will be enjoyed by little kids only. Ricepudding was excellent. Read more
Staff was very quick to get to us, and very attentive. Food was ready within about 20 minutes, and the servings were rather... generous. Overall, good value for the money. Read more