Reviews for Papacino's Bagels, Deli & Catering in Deer Park, NY

Probably the worst bagel I?ve ever had. Could barely bite through it because of how hard it was. I just went here because of the... 4 star rating it has but I will never be back. Read more

Been to this place a few times and they used to be great now their trash. They overcharge and when called on it don't even... apologize for it. 3 separate times I ordered an omelette which on their displayed menu says comes with toast or bagel. All 3times they tried to charge me for the bagel. I gave it some time and said let's see if they got better. So I ordered Frenchtoast with a couple of scrambled eggs since they list egg add-on for 85 cents. They then charged me 3.50 for the eggs. I'mdone giving them chances and you should not give them your money. Read more

I don?t normally write a lot of reviews, but then I typically tend to have good experiences. I went to this deli 2 days ago.... Staff was rude. Not only rude but I was uncomfortably checked out by a man who worked there. It was so demeaning. The food wasnot great. The egg sandwiches were somehow soggy but the eggs were so dry. I ordered an Italian sandwich and the amount ofdressing on this leaked out into the bag in the time I walked out and to my car to pass the sandwiches out to the passengers inmy car. Don?t recommend Read more

Such delicious and perfectly toasted garlic bagel and egg everything bagel I ever had with pastrami, egg overeasy and cheese... with pepper ketchup thank you. Excellent customer service next time I'll take a picture we were just too hungry. Serve your owncoffee and get to pick a few flavors like French vanilla and caramel Read more

I ordered breakfast sandwiches one of them being bacon and eggs with cheese , the other was sausage, egg and cheese. They were... both well cooked and the cheese was gooey just as I love it. Hmm..... Read more

I?ve always liked their food and service in the past and never had any issues until today. The woman at register was wiping... her sweat from her forehead and then handling the food without gloves. There was also hair in the breakfast platter I orderedand the avocado was completely brown (borderline rotten). When the owner is present - the business is definitely ran differentand it showed today with his absence. Hoping today was just a hiccup - might consider returning. Read more

Working in the area, and looking for a decent deli sandwich. Found this spot. It was highly rated, and people seem to be loving... their cheesesteaks and sandwiches. So, I decided to head on over. It?s a tiny spot. So, I waited a bit before going in sincethere was already 4 other people inside and that literally took up all the space inside. When I got in. I was kinda of thrownoff that everyone else had on a mask but the lady behind the counter taking orders. There was another woman doing sandwiches &she had a mask on thankfully. I ordered the ?Stallone Cheesesteak? and the Papacino Italiano w/ no tomatoes. The Italiano wasgood, but could be better. Too much dressing, and the peppers made the hero super mushy. It tasted ok, nothing spectacular. Nowthe Stallone was sub par to say the least. I had high hopes for this one after reading all the great reviews about theirsandwiches. The combo of hot Italian sausage and steak sounded pretty nice. However the execution was poor. The steak was overcooked and chewy & lacked flavor. The sausage was almost non existent in the sandwich & the pieces I had tasted bland. Thetomato sauce made the sandwich a mess to eat & not in a good way. That hero was nothing close to garlicky. I didn?t even finishit. It wasn?t very appealing to eat. Too chewy and flavors were off. Maybe I?ll give them another shot? But that?s a hugemaybe. Parking is available. Variety of drinks to choose from. If you pay with card they charge you more. Staff wasn?t the mostpolite. Read more

Favorite place to get breakfast from Chuck is a food making genius he should just open up a restaurant already. It?s a warm and... friendly atmosphere with down to earth people working their butts off. Food is always delicious the macaroni salad is the bombfreshly made not the bucket garbage kind that other places sell. The beer cheese is one of my favorite add ons to any breakfastor lunch sandwich. Wish I still lived local I?d be there more often! Read more