Reviews for Magruders Restaurant & Pub in Depew, NY
The staff was terrible. ?Confused? about our party. Inappropriate comments made through the lunch in by Diane and the owner. He... cleared a plate and said ?i knew i should have charged per plate!? As the person was told to help themselves to seconds. Feltrushed and took away the food all within 30 mins. Diane saying it?s so hard working for family. It was a terrible experience. Idon?t think someone could pay me to go back there and deal with the staff. Make sure to look at your bill a few times. Chargesthat were never once negotiated on the check. Diane said ?go on the website? 0/10 recommend! ????? Read more
Bad experience?.waitress/ bartender very rude food wasn?t great and neither was my drink. Very disappointed
This place would probably be awesome if the bartender didn't have to run around by herself running the bar and having to cook.... She did a great job serving everyone but there's only so much one person can do by themselves. Read more
Great food & service, tender stuffed roast beef, fresh mashed potatoes, everything excellent. We were there Saturday the 30th of... July after my sister's Memorial Service, they were so understanding, wonderful, we'll go back again and again, great place ! 5stars ???????????????????? Read more
Had an after party here recently that went very smoothly. The food was not particularly good (pizza/wings etc) but there was... plenty of it and it was all priced reasonably. Even though they were very short staffed the service was good and they kept thebuffet pretty full most of the time. Nothing impressive but it definitely served it?s purpose and the family that runs it wasgreat. Read more
Went here for the first time for a birthday party. This was arranged beforehand and nothing was set up as it should have been.... No problem, we can move tables but the owner's daughter, Diane, complained and said we can't move tables and said we can onlyeat at 2 of the 8 tables even though we rented the whole room. Also, they quoted us one price on the phone for the room as wewere ordering off the menu, not having a buffet set up, and they charged us double. They said they can't change it because "wecan't refund the amount on the register or give back cash". Diane was super unprofessional, telling us multiple conflictingstatements such as "there is no cook on Sunday as we don't serve food on Sundays" and in the same breath "We sent the cook hometoday since we did not know you were coming" when this was a prearranged event and confirmed 3 hours before arriving at 2pm.Also, she overshared a lot about her life which was unprofessional, and complained they can't find anyone to work and came intoour room every 5 minutes to ask if we knew anyone looking to find a job. Also, we were not notified that the menu would belimited to four items, all consisting of fried food. When we did start receiving food, it was either not what was ordered orcame out at various times. We had 13 entrees in total, and one entree that was missed until the end was for a child. There wasno organization and Diane at one point almost went to touch my infant's face while sitting in a high chair, completingunwarranted. I will not be visiting this establishment in the future, and perhaps think about hosting your events elsewhere. Read more
There with other Classmates & Guests for MHS 65 Class Reunion. Large Room, several tables & had a nice spread of Chicken Wings,... Roast Beef on Weck & plain rolls. Horseradish, Bleu cheese, salad, coffee, pop & alcohol beverages. Read more
I planned a small 65th surprise Birthday for my sweetheart and they did an awesome job..for small groups they really pulled... through and price was great..they forgot appetizer tray for early guest but they totally treated us to wonderful food. I woulddefinitely book again and family fun they treat you like family.!! Read more