Reviews for Nonna's Pizzeria in Depew, NY
Great pizza, wings, and breadsticks. Price is great for everything is great too!
I have ordered from here plenty of times and food usually excellent. The last few times the quantity and quality of food is... unacceptable. I ordered a sheet pizza with extra sauce and pizza had the least amount of sauce possible. Basically bread andcheese. I will think twice before wasting $35 again. It's a shame as I prefer to patronize locally owned businesses. Read more
Wings very small, overcooked & dry. Very disappointed, we ordered 30. Pizza ok.
After moving into the area, Nonna?s was the next pizzeria to try out. The order was promised in 25 minutes and they held up to... that promise as it was ready when we were there to pick it up in exactly 25 minutes. The pizza looked like it was just going tobe average tasting. However, this pizza really surprised me and is one of the better ones I?ve had in all of WNY. We alsotried the medium wings. The wings were cooked to perfection. I?m a stickler for good blue cheese. I for one didn?t care fortheir blue cheese. However, my daughter said it was the best blue cheese she?s ever had. So I guess you?ll just have to try itout for yourself and develop your own opinion. We will definitely be back here. Read more
Great pizza, amazing grilled wings. Looked to be family owned and ran possibly. Ordered 10 and they were nice enough to add an... extra 2 because the cook thought the wings were looking a little small Read more
BOMB pizza. Absolutely delicious pizza and wings. Maybe a little pricey but I think everything is now a days but the staff was... super friendly and accommodating. This is officially our new spot. Can?t say enough how good it was. Read more
We ordered a pizza from here for the first time last night. I've been trying to talk my husband into ordering from here for... weeks! We are on a quest to find the best pizza in town. This pizza was actually pretty good! Until I found two separate chunkyblack hairs in two different slices of our pizza baked under the cheese. I know things happen, but TWO. It was beyond gross. Ifeel bad leaving this review but when health and safety is at the forefront of everyone's mind this is inexcusable. Read more
Garlic parm wings are excellent! Pizza was solid as well. Especially if you like crispy!