Reviews for The Bay Cafe and Market in Eagle Bay, NY
Beautiful little rustic and cozy cafe! Love the details in the decor. I had the black forest latte, so good! The breakfast was... also awesome! Great and friendly service???. Read more
Had sandwich, salad, ice coffee and 7 layer bar. Great food and atmosphere. Nick nack store upstairs to shop. A must place to... eat. Read more
I've been here for breakfast and the food is delicious! However , there is not wait staff. You order your food at the counter... then go sit. If there are more than 2 in you party it will take a while for everyone at your table to get their meals . Theybring 1 plate out at a time as they finish them . After you're done you carry your own dirty plates and mugs to a big bin.There is an adorable little shop upstairs. Make sure to browse it before you leave. Read more
If you like egg shells and Italian sausage in your omelet, flies on your table, self serve drinks and table bussing, all for... $30. This place is for you. Read more
Family of 6, two adults and 4 kids. Stopped for lunch I At 2 pm Sunday 3 June 2018. Limited menu but with the wood fired... pizza, all the kids were happy. We also ordered 2 sandwiches. The meats and cheeses were thick sliced, not lunch meat Met theowner very friendly and stopped by our table to chat and say thank us. Definite place to stop and eat. Next door to the EagleBay Welcome Center. Read more
Cozy, rustic, great food, awesome service, we will definitely come back!!! Hours will be different after memorial day.
One of my favorite spots for breakfast or lunch. They have great coffee and wonderful food. Plus you can find amazing gifts and... local goodies there. Read more
Great food and great service. Friendly folks and very accommodating. Definitely will go back.