Reviews for Carmine's in Williamsville, NY
Nice place to try. Most of the food is excellent. Some of the dishes are very unhealthy and smothered with cheese. If they used... half the cheese it would be normal. The Vodka sauce needs a little less garlic. I'm being picky but overall very good. Read more
Great service. Starting off with calamari and soup for the appetizer was overall good. Entrees we got penne a la vodka was very... good but the Sicilian filet mignon had an odd flavor almost gamey like venison the asparagus that came with it was putrid it wasraw and flavorless you could tell it was charred for 3 seconds and then put on the plate. Please work on this but overallexperience was good. Read more
New location is awesome. The bar area club chairs and tables are a delightful, relaxing and sophisticated experience. Food is... as good as ever. Our bartender/server was very pleasant and attentive. Heads up, there is plenty of parking behind thebuilding. Yea, we?ll be back. . . Often. Read more
Food is tasty but had many issues. Food was salty. I ordered my stake medium rare got well done. And it was supposed to be... mushroom risotto I got asparagus. And the risotto was under cooked. Read more
Food was great...our server could have been more understanding that our two children were hungry and accommodated our request to... put their order in while three adults decided on entrees. Instead she said she didn't want to confuse the kitchen. Read more
What a great meal!! We ordered the chicken Parmesan dinner that feeds 4-6. There was 4 of us and plenty of leftovers. Great deal... for anyone not wanting to cook! Will definitely order again. Read more
Great food and Hannah the waitress is the BEST! Huge portions and it's so cozy inside. It's a great place for a night out with... the hubby or family. Will be back soon for sure! Read more
After being seated right away w reservations we waited a good 45 minutes for a so/so meal w reservations. The Chicken Bryan was... tough and lasagna was just okay. Sauce needs work to beat mine - or even Rao?s in a jar! Waste of money. Read more