Reviews for Nick & Toni's in East Hampton, NY
Beautiful iconic East Hampton spot. Warm staff, delicious pastas, Eggplant was quite tasty. Zucchini Chips are very good but... very large portion - beware of the temptation to fill up on these. Read more
Went to celebrate my daughter's 2 year old bday. The servers were very friendly and courteous, The ambience was nice. The food... and the deserts were of good quality. Read more
Fantastic dining experience, consistently strong menu items, friendly staff and overall a wonderful place
I had the most lovely evening dining here by myself at the bar last night. It was super busy when I arrived around 9pm (to be... expected at any well reviewed place on a Saturday night) but the hostess Kirsten was warm and welcoming and made sure I didn’tfeel forgotten in the crowd of folks waiting for their tables in the foyer. One of the 3 attentive bartenders Carlos suggested afabulous Rose which I ended up having 2 (ok ok 3) glasses of. I waited for a spot at the bar (whilst sipping that fab Rose) formaybe 20 min. Bartender Danny then helped me navigate the menu (2x) and I ordered the zucchini chips (can easily feed 4) whichwere absolutely delicious and the sea bass (one of the specials). It was a very hearty portion and Oh. So. Good. Danny was sofriendly and engaging with all the bar patrons, myself included. Once he left for the night Bartender Danielle took over and wasjust as pleasant, engaging and friendly as everyone else. I have zero complaints or critiques (shocking). I will certainly beback. Read more
Went tonight and had a wonderful time. Jocelyn was a wonderful waitress and I was so happy to have the chance to meet her!... Personable, kind, fun, and professional. The food was superb (as always) and I was very happy with the entire evening. Thank youfor making a celebratory night out all that much better! Read more
????What a service ! For FATHERS’Day my daughter invited me to Nick and Toni’s for dinner. As we started our dinner, my... daughter dropped a fork by accident. In just a few second, the Mgr was at our table and a waiter was also already thereimmediately with a fresh fork. I have never seen such a special attention at a restaurant.. The service was unbelievablebecause of the fantastic people working there. The food was very delicious. We are coming back as soon as we can. Specialthanks to the entire Team at Nick and Toni’s. Read more
A recommendation I’ll forever be grateful for. Vicky( our waitress) was WONDERFUL!!!! Knowledgeable , funny, kind and... fabulous. On her advise my husband and I ordered the special wild salmon. Out of this world and extremely well priced.Everything was wonderful. Will definitely return but kudos to all. A splendid evening.. Read more
Amazing Wood Oven Grilled Dishes - Great “Zucchini Fritto” in kicking off the evening - Beware of the small portions of... N&T’s Pasta Dishes, even when ordered as an entree - Picturesque Setting - Acceptable Service on a very busy Saturday night! Read more