Reviews for Antonio's Pizzeria New York in East Meadow, NY

The pizza and meat pies here are SO Soooooo good. I'm thoroughly impressed by the quality and price points. Definitely my new... favorite pizza place that also serves British pies! The owner Antonio might just be my new favorite person on Long Island, suchwarmth and passion for his craft. Just an overall awesome business owner and individual. I ordered: - The kitchen sink pie $27- it's basically a supreme pizza, loaded with toppings. - Weekly special: Grandma pie, large regular (I added prosciutto &mushroom), 6 garlic knots $40, the grandma pie was a crowd favorite. - Meatball, eggplant, chicken, sausage and pepper parmheros. 6 heros for $39.80. Exactly what I wanted. Warm crusty bread loaded with protein, sauce and cheese. - Steak & onion,steak & mushroom, chicken curry, Shepard's pie. 4 for $38. So far I've tried the steak & onion and Shepard's pie. Steak andonion is definitely my favorite. Flaky crust, tender steak, great filling! - Cannoli chip gelato $5.95. My husband said "wow ittastes like happiness!". ALL proceeds from their gelato sales goes to charity, Cancer Research Long Island. I don't evenunderstand how this business runs because they're so generous and community oriented. Other Tips: Parking was easy in front ofthe store on a Sunday at 11:30AM. If you place an order for pickup be sure to be on time! Antonio (the owner) is quitepassionate about the quality of his food and making sure it's at optimal freshness when he hands it over! Although I had hispizza at room temp and it was still stellar lol Read more

This is a great semi-hidden gem, You can tell from reviews that its popular, And although parking can sometimes be difficult..... The atmosphere, staff, and most of all the food, are worth the time to park/walk/wait for the food to arrive. This was a greatfind, and certainly worth checking out no matter where you're from. Thank ya'll for the amazing food! I'll definitely come backfor more anytime im around Read more

I got a regular slice and a chicken bacon ranch slice. I was very impressed. The crust had excellence texture and flavor. Great... sauce and great cheese too. The chicken bacon ranch was very good with a good ratio between toppings. Very affordable as well. Read more

Fantastic pizza place. I think the combination of pizza and British pub food is amazing and incredibly innovative. I'll be back... here soon for sure. Read more

This place is an odd combination of pizza parlor / British pie shop the Italian food is decent at a decent price. Last week we... went there and got Baked Ziti and something called a Balti pie, the ziti was good & nice size portion the Balti pie was good.Today we decided to try the British stuff, ordered a steak & mushroom pie, a Vegetarian steak & mushroom pie, a vegetarian roll,and a sausage roll. 1st the 2 rolls were in the same container which is a no no since 1 was vegan, also there was no way todistinguish which was which, finally they were cold. Next the steak & mushroom was in a different container from the veganversion however they put an identifying sticker directly on top of each pie instead of on the container, finally both of thesewere cold as well. So I previously recommended this place on Twitter now I retract my recommendation. Read more

03/07/2022 updated Just got Grandma Pizza This is the best and highly recommended.Everyone love it! The best pizza ever.Made... with passionate.I ordered Margaretta pizza.This is the True taste of Capri! This pizza made me thinking of the whole ITALY. Theyalso has the best Gilato. Try it yourself and believe me. This is the best! Read more

I was far from a fan of Angelo’s the previous place, even the cheaper prices didn’t make it worth it but so far this is... really great pizza. I will definitely try again and it has a very good chance based on this first experience of being my go toplace. Nice sauce and a solid crisp, even after being delivered, has this vying for top East Meadow spot. Read more

With coupons, Large pie with sausage and 12 pieces of buffalo wings for 25 dollars with tax. I think its a good deal. The pizza... and wings both taste good. The shop has small store front, but easy to find parking. They also make delivery too. Read more