Reviews for Sammy's Original Pizza Inferno in East Meadow, NY

His cannolis are pretty good, can't beat the price. $1.5 each for a large cannolis. He has a bunch of different... fillings/toppings. He has an absolutely amazing deal for pizza. $10 for a cheese pizza. This pizza his large (more like mediumlarge). Add toppings for only a dollar or two. What a great price. The crust was crispy with a great amount of leoparding. Thesauce was a little sweet and had a fresh basil taste. And to top it off, my man Sammy puts a good amount of cheese Read more

I ordered carry out for a large pie and half dozen garlic knots for $12. Based on the previous google reviews by other people I... was expecting very tasty pizza. Immediately after we got home and opened the box, I knew I was going to be disappointed. Thepizza looked old and soggy, with burn marks in several places. The cheese was inconsistent and rubbery with an odd taste. Thesauce was barely present and was dry. The crust was either overcooked or undercooked. It seemed that the pizza had been madehours ago then reheated and served to us. The garlic knots were bland and tasted like raw dough. Overall the food wasdisgusting. The only redeeming quality was the positive attitude and cheerfulness of the owner and pizza maker behind thecounter when we first walked in. Other than that, a complete waste of money. Granted this may have been a one bad experienceamong several other good ones, but the pizza was so bad that I want to know what kind of pizza everyone else got that warranted4 plus stars. Would not reccomend or try again. Read more

NY Pizza as it used to be. Brought back memories of Levittown in the 60's. Cheese pizza with a touch of parmesan cheese and... oregano added is the way to go. Owner is son of early owner who uses the original recipe from when he tossed pizza as a teensnd young man. This is the real deal... after 40 years of marriage and raving about NY Pizza, I finally showed my wife what itis... would drive a ling way for more.... please open up in Richmond, VA ... A loyal fan.... Read more

this place brings me back 25 years ago when they were in levittown when I moved to levittown this was the first pizza place I... hit. it was the only one I went to it was a sad day when they closed. but happy days are here again it's the same pizza andsauce and everything else. it is still outrageous it may be even a little better. a must place to go nice people great pricesand the food brings you back in time. Read more

Stopped by for a slice onwer was super friendly. His pizza was second to none. If you enjoy a well made pie then this place is a... must try!!! Will not be my last time going. Read more

Pizza was cold, said the order would be ready in half an hour, it wasn't. Everyone that worked there was sitting out side in the... back parking lot of the pizzaria, and people that did not seem to work there were walking around the kitchen and service area.Cashier didn't know how to process a cc transaction. Would not go back there at all. Read more

Incredibly friendly, welcoming atmosphere. They did a beautiful job renovating this place! I wish I had taken some pictures of... my slices, they were perfect. We ordered three slices all together, one Sicilian, one cheese, one pepperoni, each equally asamazing. The owner was so low key and easy going, he did not rush us out and even let us try out some of their delicious garlicknots and let us pay after eating. I will be back as much as possible. They even have the old cash register from the oldLevittown store out on display! #Nostalgia Read more

I have eaten from here several times because I live around the block. They have awesome Pizza the sauce is amazing and their... Stromboli is simply out of this world; I have never had a better Stromboli before in my life.... also their meatball parm heroreally good too!!!!!!! Read more