Reviews for Red Tomato Pizza in East Norwich, NY
used to love coming here with my family & friends. i visited today & i personally had an unpleasant experience with the service.... the waitress was very abrupt, slamming drinks, food down on table. never checked on us once. forgot to give us our iced teas &when we reminded her, she took another 5 minutes to get them for us (they were bottled beverages). she charged me for the wrongtable & as i was about to tell her she reached across my arm that was noticeably in a sling because i had just gotten surgery &she ripped the check out of my hand. it was very rude & to say the least i won’t be coming back. i’ve been dining here sincei was in high school & used to recommend it to everyone. my friend who was with me came for the first time, and she was equallyirritated with the service given to us today. Read more
This restaurant has new owners and the quality of the food and service has plummeted. I had chicken parmigiana and it was cold.... Sent it back to warm it up and it was still cold. My chicken cutlet had a bone in it!! My wife had eggplant and it was the worstone she ever had. The eggplant was not breaded like it should be and big chunks of mozzarella cheese were just thrown in it!!Hers was cold also. The Cesar salad came out with our meals and the waitress just put everything down on the tabletogether.There were basically two people trying to run the business. Had to ask for more water. Customer from outside had tocome in with her glasses to ask for more water. I had a $100 gift card we received for Christmas and they would not honor it!!Wouldn’t honor value of any Groupons we also had that weren’t used due to Covid. We use to love this restaurant but we willnever go back. I just don’t understand the positive reviews it received?? I didn’t even want to talk to anyone there as itwas my last visit ever. Read more
Was craving pizza and always wanted to try this place and boy it did not disappoint. The ambiance, friendly staff and... cleanliness was more than I expected. The dough was so fluffy and perfectly baked. Our waitress was so sweet and patient,especially with us having 3 kids. Everything was made fresh and I will definitely be coming back and making this part of myweekly pizza Fridays. Cant wait to try more stuff on the menu. Read more
The worst thing about this place is that. THE BREAD IS SO GOOD I CANT STOP EATING IT!!! I order pizza from here often, but even... the sandwiches and salads are good enough to literally eat every day. I’ve never tasted dough like theirs. I love the staff,Irene is always there and so sweet and welcoming. The space is clean and the decor is awesome. #selfienation Definitelyrecommend! Read more
Went here for the first time yesterday for dinner. The food and service was absolutely phenomenal. Legitimately the best... brick oven pizza restaurant around, with a variety of options! The tartufo pizza is by far my absolute favorite! Read more
So yummy! Passed by this place on Northern millions of times and finally decided to go in. Glad we did...super good food and... lovely staff. Gorgeous decor and very comfortable seating too! Read more
Found this gem after a hike at Muttontown Preserve. Had an excellent wood fired margarita pizza with cauliflower crust and the... tomato basil soup. The setting is more upscale than a pizzeria and the prices reflect it, but worth a little extra. Will goback to try more of the extensive menu items. Read more
Really enjoyed the special attention and quality of our entrees tonight! Pizza was super Neapolitan authentic and the staff was... really nice to our table. (awesome salads too! ????) Read more