Reviews for Cosimo’s Italian-American Cuisine in East Patchogue, NY

We eat here at least once a week. Food is always fresh and delicious. Just the right amount of seasoning and cooked to... perfection. Hats off to the chef and the staff for consistently providing excellent service. Shrimp scampi and salmon are myfavorites! Read more

Wow! Amazing food and great drinks. It was a extremely busy night, music was great! Crystal our server is the best! They rallied... up to make sure everyone was happy!! Read more

I went here for a special occasion. Mambo Loco Band was playing and the latin theme also surrendered to a special menu of... Pernil, rice and beans, and a heavenly potato salad. Absolutely looking forward to trying their Italian food. Note to owner:continue inviting live bands and place event in local calendars. You should be known. Great people and great time Read more

First visit to Cosimo?s. Comfortable atmosphere. It was a comedy of errors but the owner Cosimo was very welcoming and... courteous, Our server Gabby was sweet but the manager not so much. We will definitely give it another try. Read more

The staff was great, friendly, and very attentive. The food was exceptional. I had the Chicken Piccata. The chicken was... tender and the taste was light and delicious. The pasta was cooked to perfection. Will definitly be back. Read more

My first time here. All day I was craving Clams. I had the Linguini with clams. It was fresh, great sauce. Excellent! I wish I... lived here to do a return visit. Read more

Food-10/10! Customer service- 10/10! Atmosphere- 10/10 I have lived down the street from Cosimos since I was a little girl and... yesterday was my first time ever going. The experience was not great due to a clearly inexperienced server (he was onlycovering) the owner himself made sure we left that restaurant with a smile and assured us this was not an accuraterepresentation of his business and from the reviews and the way he made sure we left happy I believe him. Now about theimportant part! THE FOOD!!!! We had CHICKEN MARSALA, LOBSTER RAVIOLI, STUFFED MEATBALLS, and since the waiter put in the wrongorder for me first I got to taste the SEAFOOD RAVIOLIS. The food was SO DELICIOUS! It had so much flavor! So good in fact Iwent back today and got the FRIED CALAMARI AND PENE ALA VODKA and it was just as Delicious! I had the tell the owner he wasright, he told me once I had the food I?d surly be back, he was so right! This is going to be my new regular spot for sure. Read more

We got take out. Everything was just average. We got rice balls, giant meatball, chicken parm and side of grilled chicken.... Nothing blew us away. For the price we were disappointed. We did not like the meatball. It tasted like the meat was expired Read more