Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Eaton, OH
Cory was my driver and he was extremely polite! The pizza was amazing especially the Buffalo chicken ???? ???? ???? ????
It's a chain pizza pretty much the same everywhere. But our food has ALWAYS been meticulously good at this location in Eaton... Ohio. Since there isn't alot of choices for pizza it's good to know they are here! Read more
Very good! Oh how I have miissed Papa John's pizza! Everything was hot and we had a big order, it was done in time for us to eat... and go back to work in a timely fashion! Outstanding! Read more
Pizza was OK for me. Not a big papa John's fan but the family is. If going at night especially on weekends be prepared for a... Wait. They get crazy busy. Waiting on our carry out we saw first hand. The employees were non stop getting the pizzas made andout the door. Very impressed by this crew. Read more
Seriously the best Papa John's I've ever been to. Always super consistent with the pizza: never undercooked, super cheesy,... super crispy pepperoni. I've ordered here probably a dozen times and I'm totally impressed every time. If you live anywhereNEAR here and want Papa John's, take the extra time to go to the Eaton location. SO, so much better than any other place. Honestly don't understand what's up with these bad reviews because everyone I've ever talked to in town loves this place. Read more
UPDATE 1/30/2021 Much better this time. Changed from three to five stars. Thanks guys! We?ve eaten pizza more this year than... usual, and have been very impressed with the food quality and the service of the Eaton PJ?s location. Today the service wasfine, but the pizza seemed a little under done and was not as hot as usual. Also most of the ingredients were in the center ofthe pie which kind of defeats the definition of a Works pizza. It would maybe be more understandable if they had been slammed(which is usually the case when we?ve ordered there) but they were not busy at all this afternoon. The parking lot was almostempty. We got Jalapeño poppers too, and they were fine. We?ll definitely give them another chance based on our pastexperiences. Read more
I?ve always had great pizza from Papa Johns in Eaton. Tonight there was a mix up in my order when it arrived. The driver was... very nice and apologetic. When I called the store to get my order corrected they went above and beyond to make things right.THANK YOU!! Read more
Great service, pizza was just like it???????? ???? ???? ????