Reviews for Bad Martha Farmers Brewery in Edgartown, MA

Great staff, but insanely overpriced and mediocre beer. I think it's really weird when breweries don't put prices on their... menu. The only place I've seen no drink prices is at an airport. If you're going to charge $10 for a pint and $15 for a flight,the beer better be decent. It was mediocre at best. I understand this is a tourist destination, but there's definitelysomething shady about not being upfront about cost. The IPA was malt forward which was odd for a beer brewed with Mosaic. Thestout was okay. Across the pond wasn't particularly good. With beer on MV, it's best to go to a good taphouse or just buy beerat a store. What's brewed here isn't good. I'd probably go back for the pizza though. It looked delicious. Read more

Pizza and beer was very good. Outdoor seating was nice but crowded. There was no wait list for tables so it was chaotic to find... a place to sit. They were understaffed so the only way to order was inside. I found the prices high for any place but theVineyard. Read more

Dog friendly!! Love the outdoor seating and that you can bring the kids to this quaint graft brewery. The rustic garden ambiance... was our favorite part. Read more

Beers are decent with a few great ones (the quad and 508 were my fave). Great outdoor seating with a pleasant vibe surrounded by... a garden. Get the capresce salad and the charcuterie. Read more

Lots of craft beer on tap. Outside seating. Nice place.

Bad Martha has been one of our frequent stops when travel to the Vineyard. It?s been quite a few years since we stumbled upon... what was a new solid wood construction barn nestled just on the outskirts of downtown Edgartown. Today it still brings joy tosettle up with a cold local brewed beer. The structure is immediately adjacent to a local nursery where the scenery is that ofan eclectic garden with plant-life just surrounding the quaint patio where both locals & tourist will gather outside to chill &have a refreshing beverage. What a relaxing afternoon or evening to join family & friends. The beer selection is often arotational effort that may boast a Pale Ale, Helles, Stout, Porter, or even something a bit more experimental. Typically about7-10 variations or so to choose from & on visit 7/6/2021 they even had a locally sourced ingredient, house made strawberry mintseltzer at 6.4 ABV on tap for light fare. As of recent they have begun to expand their charcuterie & cheese plates snacking toinclude house made pizza & a variety of luncheon & munching options. If you find yourself in town stop by, have a beer, &tell-?Em Scotty sent ya! Read more

Very cool craft brewery - a real gem with delicious craft beer, a rustic setting, nice indoor/outdoor seating and an amazing... garden center out back. The tshirts and swag for sale was also a hit with the family. A little pricey but worth it for thequality and great taste. Highly recommended! Read more

Cute place with great craft beer. Their pizza is delicious but be sure to go early. They stop serving pizza after 8pm. The... atmosphere is rustic and beautiful and they have Cornhole. Bring your kids and dogs too! Read more