Reviews for Casey's in Edinburgh, IN
The pizza is always way under cooked if you disagree you are only lying to yourself...
BBQ brisket pizza is definitely off the chain. Very delicious pizza. I would recommend to anyone in the area. It's worth the 20... bucks, I promise. Cheese was never ending stringy, nice smoked flavor from the meat, and very light fluffy crust. Excellentpizza man, that chef needs a raise. Read more
Jodi was nothing but rude and everytime I order my pizza is always wrong. The evening staff is extremely rude and the only one... with an apology was the new guys which was appreciated. Because Jodi kept making rude remarks the whole time I was in the store.Circle K is down the street and so is dominos . We don't have to shop here!!!! Read more
Usually eat here on lunch and occasionally I'll get their breakfast pizza. One thing I can say for certain.. Their breakfast... pizza (bacon, egg & cheese) is the BEST pizza I have ever ate in my entire life!! Along with their Taco Pizza! Side note: Whenordering the Taco Pizza, get the nacho cheese chips on the side (and tomatoes as well, if that's your thing). Otherwise, thechips will be a bit soggy (which is to be expected) and the tomatoes will be mushy after so long. It'll make a difference whenyou decide to reheat a few slices later, if you have leftovers. ???????? Read more
Really nice employees, great food. Update, day time employees are questionable. I stood waiting for 10 minutes while the lady... in the food side was on the phone. There was no food being prepared. She got off the phone asked me what I wanted. A sandwichwas all I needed, yet I was told it would be a 30 minute wait. I was right in front of her. Why did I need to wait 30minutes???she couldnt grill my chicken while preparing other food?? Why is there only one person working the restaurant side.They cant keep up with customers coming in the door maybe they shouldnt be taking phone orders!! Lost my business. Neither yourfood or your work ethics are worth a 30 minute wait!!!!! Read more
There manager will not stay to help you if its time for her to leave. She will argue with you and scream at you. They do have... bomb pizza but the last pizza we got had hardly any bacon ???? and they always run out of my fav candy it is a top seller inthat store order more I know theres a budget but really i have to be there truck day to get any Read more
Love my pizza and the lady's in there are always great with service! In the rewards app there is often times something offered... for free and just buying things adds up points for free Casey's cash! It's entirely worth it. Read more
The guy who made our pizzas tonight "Mike" please DO NOT LEAVE (UNLESS, u have a better job opportunity), but Mike made the most... fabulous pizzas, absolutely THE BEST!!! It was so heavy IK it was gonna be good. TY Mike best pizza from here or janky otherpizza places. I will return as long as you make my ???? Read more