Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Edison, NJ
Ordered the large square margarita pie. It certainly was a good pie but fell short as far as the size. It was supposed to be... 16in but after picking it up I noticed it seemed smaller and it was. It was only just 13 inches and for $24 pickup I’m overallnot pleased. Again, good pie but overpriced and MISLEADING as to what you will get. Read more
This is my first negative restaurant review. I ordered wings and pizza from Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings. All food was... burnt. I visited a lot of pizzerias in the US and I never met such a disgusting attitude from the kitchen to the client. Thewaitress was nice and I'm sorry that she had to listen to a negative opinion about the food what she brought from the kitchen. Iwill never visit Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings again. Read more
Service was excellent. Eggplant Marino Pizza was good but needed another layer of eggplant (it’s so deliciously thin that 1... layer doesn’t cut it because of all the sauce that you put on it). But the WORSE thing was that they charged me $24.99 whenthe price on the menu is $22.99 (see photo)!! No I didn’t complain in the restaurant (because I had to check the menu on theway out). Please give my $2 to the server, she was very attentive!! It’s the principle Anthony!! Don’t charge your customersdifferent prices than what’s on the menu!!!! Read more
Absolutely very delicious pizza!!! You can taste the quality ingredients (I had the margherita pizza). Priced fairly and... portioned well. Classic Italian salad and cheesecake were also very very good! Overall 5 ?? for quality, taste, and friendlystaff! I will be back for more :). My food order was to-go** Read more
Not many places live up to my NY pizza expectations but I love a good Anthony's pie. Just a different pizza experience and the... side salad is a fresh crisp yummy add-on Read more
The experience at Anthony's was outstanding tonight! From the time we walked into the restaurant the ambiance was exquisitely... radiant with a calm and friendly atmosphere. Our waitress Mia is fantastic! She provided a very warm welcome and was extremelypleasant. Mia was professional and kind which also adds a nice touch. The wings were something out of this world! By far thebest I've had and I eat out often, the chard taste and the flavor was amazingly delicious, our pizza's were perfectly crafted aswell. The Manager Bob is an exceptional person as well, he came over and gave us a friendly warm welcome and shared acomplimentary meatball appetizer which was delightful, he definitely added to the experience. I must say our overall experiencewas stellar and I can't wait to visit again in the near future. Just exceptional! Read more
Highly recommend Anthony’s Coal Fired pizza! First off the pizza is delicious but also the customer service is amazing! Bobby... and Robert and all the staff went above and beyond for our kids pizza making experience. We are a special needs camp and theydid everything they could to accommodate us - so much kindness and patience. Thank you for a great experience we will beback!!!! Read more
The pizza was good. The wings were just okay. I have definitely had better food in New Jersey. The beers were also plain in the... sense that they lack variety. I liked the atmosphere, and the service was excellent! Kudos to the servers, you were amazing! Read more