Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Effingham, IL
Andrew Miller delivered my food quickly and had amazing manners. 10/10 guy
We called in our order and they told us and estimated time for it to be ready. It was done a few minutes before. There were... plenty of toppings and cheese. We love Papa John's pizza, it is always delicious. ???????????? Read more
We tried the pepperoni stuffed crust pizza and it was so good! It was made fast and employee's greeted me as soon as I walked in... the door. Read more
I called in to order the epic stuffed crust pizza and a few garlic sauces this evening.The order taker was very unprofessional... and sounded as if he didn?t even want to be working, I asked him what size this pizza comes in he replied medium and large. SoI placed an order for a large for pickup/carry out. Picked it up and took it home and it was not the pizza I ordered at all.Instead I was given a non stuffed crust pizza, with pepperoni and mushrooms. I paid for an epic stuffed crust and didn?treceive it. Only thing that was right was two garlic sauce cups. Read more
The food was amazing! We love 45 minutes away so we ordered they said 45 minutes, well we drove all the way there and they... hadn't even started it so we had to sit in the parking lot another 30 minutes. We didn't complain because the 3 cooks and 3 of 4drivers were literally working their butts off! Read more
Why did I ask for the customer appreciation special and was told that they could do a large 2 toppings for $10.74. When I went... to pick up the pizza on the counter was a piece of paper advertising for the customer appreciation special for $6.99 for a large2 topping pizza. Read more
Always correct on my orders and pizza is warm when i pick up. The manager, Sam, helped us with our perfect pizza!! Thanks
You know I normally wouldn't give a 5 star review. But having mentioned that I say this. The quality at this location is second... to none. My family frequently visits this location. We had a small bit of trouble with an order and the manager/ owner, morethan made up for it. It was beyond what I would have expected as I would've been happy with a simple apology. This place willcontinue to be our regular pizza place for family pie night. Read more