Reviews for Geno Nottolini's Pizza & Catering Company in Elgin, IL

The pizzas and pastas are excellent. We like the Wednesday pasta special where you get a second entree for a dollar. It gets 4... stars instead of 5 because of the launchy music playing. Prices are reasonable. I always call for pick up, we never eat there.It is clean but there are only about a dozen chairs. Read more

Simple, but important requests not honored caused this review to drop two stars. Simple: easy cheese and well done (for flavor)... Important: No-contact, leave at front door stating I will see you! (so dog doesn?t bark) Didn?t help that I paid for extrapepperoni and was disappointed. Trying to not let that one influence too much, but it?s hard. Read more

Very disappointed in the meat sauce. sooooo oily, upset my stomach. for the love of god, please drain the meat of its grease... before adding the meat to the sauce. grease floats on top making it disgusting to eat. Read more

We got the Wednesday Special buy one pasta get one for 99 cents. We had chicken Alfredo and one was mushrooms and Alfredo. On... the chicken alfredo the sauce was watery and there weren't very many noodles. The mushroom Alfredo was good. I feel this placehas been hit or miss when ordering from them. We won't be ordering pasta any time soon from here again Read more

Good chicago pizza joint Sauce is great Pizza crust is cooked to perfection Perfect ratio of ingredients. ONLY NEGATIVE , which... can not allow me to rate it 5 stars , IS THE CHEESE !!! It?s almost like processed cheese from a bag. If they could spend theextra money and get some fresh cheese to shred and throw on there I?d buy a pizza or two at least a week Read more

We ordered via doordash and the food was really delicious! I got the chicken Parmesan and my husband got a pizza. We also got... the salad with their Italian dressing which was very good. Way better than I expected especially having it delivered. Hot,fresh, and tasty. Big portions and reasonable prices. Will definitely be back! Read more

Always order pizza here when I?m in town and decided to order a pan pizza and wings and I must say I hit the jack pot with this... one!!! Good job guys!!! Read more

Best pizza that I have ever had and the service was amazing, I would order here again!